Beginner Mafia Game #1

[Trigger Unhappy]

My take on things right now.

When fallen was given a chance to defend himself he called out Hoshiro and Assassin as scummy. I think we can safely give them the benefit of the doubt and say they have a high probability to be town.

Pass and I were the first to call out Fallen (Hosh was first to vote for him) and Fallen kept calling me out for inactivity, which I think gives me some credibility.

That leaves Wolf, Minjae and Phil.

Wolf was the 4th vote on Fallen, but has not given me any reason to believe he is scummy. yet.

Phil voted to hammer Fallen. He has had previous suspicion thrown on him and he is dirty. But he also was the one that first unvoted Hoshiro.

Minj did not vote for Fallen. I have called out my suspicion of him in an earlier post. Honestly at this point I think it is either Phil or Minj, but I trust phil slightly more..

Vote Minjae

- - - Updated - - -

Also to answer phils question.. I think there would be 1 mafia and 1 cop left in play.

[phil.™]

You guys are doing all the work for me.

[hoshiro-]

asians, im telling you man, them asians are always fishy

- - - Updated - - -

and phil, i meant in the next game if I am mafia

[minjae]

Ok..That's interesting. I'm working out right now but I'll post what I can for now.

Apparently jumping on a lynch train isn't scummy right? No matter if it's their partner.

I kept my sights on one person which is assassin. Go ahead and lynch me if you want.
There's no point. Just know you're wasting a lynch.

[phil.™]

Min, you should have voted for fallen. I would have been way less fishy about you and would have investigated ass.
I am the town cop and investigated you. You are indeed mafia goon.

vote min

- - - Updated - - -

Min, you should have voted for fallen. I would have been way less fishy about you and would have investigated ass.
I am the town cop and investigated you. You are indeed mafia goon.

vote min

[Trigger Unhappy]

Sweet good job Phil

- - - Updated - - -

Any cc?

[Wolfenstinger]

Quick - Kill phil before night hits so we can get the other 2 mafia members and call it game. :smirk:

[hoshiro-]

So can I be MVP for starting the lynch train on vote the mafias?

- - - Updated - - -

Both*

[Nemesis]

With six players alive, it take 4 votes to lynch.

There are cuttently 3 votes for minj and one for Phil.

[minjae]

What if Phil is fake claiming? What if there is no cop?

Vote Phil

[Trigger Unhappy]

What if Phil is fake claiming? What if there is no cop?

Vote Phil

If that was true it would be stupid to do it now. Someone would counterclaim him, or after we lynched you and found out you were town, Phil would be next.

[phil.™]

Must i break it down?


Vote Phil

Because I know he's not awake by 6
Already starting with lies

- - - Updated - - -

And on a side note...I missed the sunrise on the beach. Shit.
Started with the lie. Scummy, petty but a lie. Could have been a bad lynch if people believed it.




Vote Hoshiro

Vote hosh

Vote Hosh

LOL are we doing this again? I feel bad if we do. Hahah
But here we go puhaha
Vote Hosh

Following a random vote lynch?


Will change my vote tomorrow too trigger because he hasn't contributed anything yet apart from confirming and could possibly be afk for long periods of time.This could cause problems later on.
unvote
Now off sleep.




Puhaha wow..I think you're over thinking things.
And no ass pictures for you if you're voting to lynch me....-_-
And also I wasn't gonna keep my vote in..psh I'm just trying to get people to talk.
Unvote

Following your fellow mafia unvote to seem less suspicious?




From a no lynch, to a vote lynch, that's scummy as fuck.
I have always stuck with wanting to vote, and had my eyes on hosh and min. Trig inactivity got me suspicious as well.
But this, previous games shows this is scummy as fuck.
Vote assassin
- - - Updated - - -
Pass gave few examples, not flawless examples. As did I. I gave examples why I would want a vote, not a no lynch.
So you saying pass is giving flawless answers is very scummy.


Little surprised with how Assassin is playing.. and still think that town needs to lynch day 1. Unvote Vote Assassin
- - - Updated - - -
Also can we get an updated vote tally?


Yeah, I don't know...voting a no lynch and then alla sudden to lynch is fishy.
Even with Pass' explanation.

I still think we need to lynch. We may hit an important role, if there is in fact one, or we could hit mafia.
Of course there's the in between too.
I have no idea who we should vote. Assassin is being quite scummy so far.
I'm gonna have to go with that for now and see where we go from there.

Vote assassin

Again following a vote lynch?


Yeah, we're not getting anywhere. I'm still keeping my vote on Assassin. You guys keep changing your votes lol

And damn Pass...that was the most confusing, detailed shit ever. lolol
This is where you got me. I clearly said to ass and everyone he may not be mafia, it's just a scummy play. You refused to switch your vote to fallen.

[Trigger Unhappy]

Wolf, Assassin any counter? otherwise vote.

[phil.™]

THe only reason why I asked if there could be a possible 3rd mafia, I didn't want to give up my role as town cop. If there is a 3rd mafia, we would go night 2, I would be lynch, and town is fucked with a random vote lynch next day, most likely ending in a loss for town.

- - - Updated - - -

I would be killed at night* not lynched.

[Trigger Unhappy]

I know, just have no idea why wolf didnt vote when he was in here.. game could be over.

[phil.™]

I know, just have no idea why wolf didnt vote when he was in here.. game could be over.

It's... because...
I didn't shower. Damn it wolf. STOP WATCHING ME. STAY IN UPPER BMORE.

[Wolfenstinger]

I'm coop. Phil did murdesr.

Unvote

Vote Minjae

Lynched. Also Phil -> I'm near like Quarterfield, Severn, Millersville, Glen Burnie. That area. Not in Bmore at all. Also you still smell. :icon_mrgreen:

[Assassin]

Yeah step up

[phil.™]

I'm coop. Phil did murdesr.

Unvote

Vote Minjae

Lynched. Also Phil -> I'm near like Quarterfield, Severn, Millersville, Glen Burnie. That area. Not in Bmore at all. Also you still smell. :icon_mrgreen:

Lol, that anne arundel county lol.
My shop is off of route 2 and mountain road.

You me, and the mafia should get a drink together.

[Wolfenstinger]

stfu lynched happened.

Also your shops off route 2....

I technically could stop in and say you smell. o_O

[phil.™]

Possibly. I'm right near marley station.
But i shower every other 17 days, but I wear calvin klein cologne, so it's technically like every other 12 days.

[Passarelli]

Nice. I'll have to stop in when I go back to Maryland to visit my parents. I'd fly into BWI most likely then stay at my grandmother's. My parents live beyond the pinch though.

[Trigger Unhappy]

Nice. I'll have to stop in when I go back to Maryland to visit my parents. I'd fly into BWI most likely then stay at my grandmother's. My parents live beyond the pinch though.

Death to the Ghost!!!

[minjae]

Mehhh.
But yeah. Everybody come and let's chill.

[Wolfenstinger]

Mehhh.
But yeah. Everybody come and let's chill.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sTbc2NeErnU

I gotchu.

[Trigger Unhappy]

Come to madison guys...

[hoshiro-]

Sure don't invite hoshiro :/

[Nemesis]

Ok that's a lynch.

Minjae, the Mafia Goon has been lynched.

AND

that's the game! The Town has won.

[phil.™]

Any vets who has been following up on this have feedback for us? Other than "you morons took 24 fucking pages to get through day 1 with 8 people?"
Although it took this long, I feel like i got enough information on each player to see who was who, giving me the right investigation on min.

[minjae]

The longest, quickest game ever...stupid.
Fallen got lynched first day, that sucked. We talked too fucking long, that sucked. I got investigated because of that, that sucked. Got lynched day 2, that sucked.

It was fun tho. I really was going to lynch fallen, but Phil beat me to it. I probably should have lynched him sooner.
I knew there was a cop and a doctor. Shit lolol I was thinking it was Phil or Pass that was cop, but ended up getting the doctor which wasn't too bad. Had it not been for the quick lynches.

But all in all, I learned a lot being on the mafia side. Hopefully in the future games I'll also have more insight and better deducting skills in whatever role I get.

[phil.™]

Just curiosity pass, who were you protecting night 1?

[Passarelli]

You of course! I knew one of us was going to die. Either me for pointing out Fallen or you for hammering him.

[phil.™]

Bandwagon someone. I dont feel comfortable with mafia going into the night without us lynching anyone.
Best case scenario, we lynch a mafia tonight. Hopefully there is a cop or sheriff, and they target scum by chance. Day 2, he outs himself and out's scum. Bam, win for town.

But that's best case scenario, and wishful thinking lol.
Lol, i called it hahaha.


You of course! I knew one of us was going to die. Either me for pointing out Fallen or you for hammering him.
I had a good feeling you were doc.

[Passarelli]

I was way too active. I need to take a page out of scribble's book when I play doctor.

Minjae, did you lynch me because I picked out fallen?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

All I have time to say is that pass was right.

You guys have to understand that no lynching is not always bad and is sometimes the only key left to winning a game as town.

[BladeTwinSwords]

The problem with having a Cop and Doctor but no Mafia Roles is that all the Doctor has to do is protect the Cop and stay hidden until the Cop learns who all the Mafia are.

[Nemesis]

A few notes,

This game was suppose to get you to talk, not be decided by some bullshit deadline or crappy modding. Assassin whined way too much.
Pass you're right, you played way too loud as a doctor.
Mafia segregated yourselves a bit too much, fallen, when accused you should have tried to make someone else look like the target rather than just say "it's not me" Doing so would have possibly changed you getting lynched.
Blade, they had no idea if there was a cop so Phil couldn't out himself confidently.
Pass, your "notes" were fucking stupid, never post that again.


All in all it wasn't too bad, but you guys need to maybe play a little more loose? Don't worry about throwing votes out. It took a little long to get anyone voting but that's not bad, the fact that there was discussion was the main focus.

So, who would be up to playing again, different set up though, maybe a few more people?

[phil.™]

Yeah, i'm down for another beginner game. Little bit more players, little bit more roles.

[Nemesis]

Yeah, i'm down for another beginner game. Little bit more players, little bit more roles.

Ya that's what i was thinking, with a few of the less pushy regs involved and a few more roles, but still a nice beginner friendly game.

[Passarelli]

I'd be up for another game.

[Trigger Unhappy]

Wait I got zero feedback on my play.

- - - Updated - - -

also i would be in for another

[hoshiro-]

Did i at least do alright in this game?

[Nemesis]

Wait I got zero feedback on my play.

- - - Updated - - -

also i would be in for another

If you were the doctor or cop, you would have played a well. You were a little inactive which almost got you lynched but here able to divert suspicions. You could have been a little more involved with discussions but not bad.

[Wolfenstinger]

So we had cop + doc
Phil = Cop
Pass = Doc
Or just a doc?

Also, after Fallen died; was easy to pick off who the last member was. Except I still wanted Phil dead. :smirk: ... All in all, Phil should've died. Nuff said. :icon_mrgreen:

[minjae]

I'm down for another game too :icon_mrgreen:

I already know what I did wrong so meh.

[phil.™]

Let's get 'errr going.

[Nemesis]

Ok. Tomorrow ill draw something up

[CYBER]

ok so i moved this thread to the previous section without closing it so that u guys can keep talking while i ask zero to do some organization voodoo for u guys, but apparently the previous section prevents from letting ppl post... I DID NOT KNOW THAT. BUT GOD THATS AWESOME.


So i moved this thread to the main section WHERE ALL NEW ACTIVE GAMES SHALL BE POSTED FROM NOW ON.