WCS themed Mafia Game

[What]

Only one whining here is you nem, you pretty much got told that you didn't play great, but you just keep screaming that you did and clearly anyone who disagrees with you is inferior. So, yeah, grow up my friend.

[Erdenay]

I still don't understand how you can be so wrong about this. Random lynch is by far the worse thing to do as town. You're at a disadvantage in numbers and you learn nothing. Random lynching is baaaad.

---------- Post added at 07:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:06 PM ----------

Also, my goal was to be loud enough to get targeted, then switch myself with people I don't like. Unfortunately when What started doing the mafia's job for them, there wasn't much else to do.

I understand the 2nd part and I agreed with that, but here's why No lynch is good:

1) Lynch is controlled by town, thus it's TOWN weapon. When you can, it should be used.
2) While somewhat random on day 1, the main thing it provides is INFORMATION. Even if you hit a town, it tends to be a great for town in the long run. If you hit mafia, even better. Right from day 1, you can come back to see patterns, you can see who was bandwagonning, who was scummaring, who was agreeing with whom, who said some things that may contradict something else later, who maybe speed-hammered, etc. No lynch is MUCH worse as all of that would be lost out.
3) Lastly, no lynch realistically leaves people at day 2 almost the same point as day 1 unless cop hits a mafia or something else just as random happens. If there is no lynch at day 1, cops and other people have to ALSO target random people for their actions rather than be INFORMED and have an idea who to target. SO yeah.

[Nemesis]

I understand the 2nd part and I agreed with that, but here's why No lynch is good:

1) Lynch is controlled by town, thus it's TOWN weapon. When you can, it should be used.
2) While somewhat random on day 1, the main thing it provides is INFORMATION. Even if you hit a town, it tends to be a great for town in the long run. If you hit mafia, even better. Right from day 1, you can come back to see patterns, you can see who was bandwagonning, who was scummaring, who was agreeing with whom, who said some things that may contradict something else later, who maybe speed-hammered, etc. No lynch is MUCH worse as all of that would be lost out.
3) Lastly, no lynch realistically leaves people at day 2 almost the same point as day 1 unless cop hits a mafia or something else just as random happens. If there is no lynch at day 1, cops and other people have to ALSO target random people for their actions rather than be INFORMED and have an idea who to target. SO yeah.

We're gonna play a game. Pick a number from one to ten. Seven of the numbers are wrong, and if you pick a wrong number, I'm going to kick you in the dick. We'll keep going until you get all three right, does that sound like fun?

[brett friggin favre]

We're gonna play a game. Pick a number from one to ten. Seven of the numbers are wrong, and if you pick a wrong number, I'm going to kick you in the dick. We'll keep going until you get all three right, does that sound like fun?

you forgot that most of the numbers have down syndrome.

[What]

you also forgot that after each pick he gains more and more info on the correct numbers, as well as it not being blind to begin with since you get to observe how these "numbers" are acting.

[Erdenay]

We're gonna play a game. Pick a number from one to ten. Seven of the numbers are wrong, and if you pick a wrong number, I'm going to kick you in the dick. We'll keep going until you get all three right, does that sound like fun?

Quite literally only works if you assume everyone's an idiot (what Brett is basically saying) and if you assume that people can't really figure anything out unless it's specifically GIVEN to them. An assumption I believe to be void.

[SCRIBBLE]

Quite literally only works if you assume everyone's an idiot (what Brett is basically saying) and if you assume that people can't really figure anything out unless it's specifically GIVEN to them. An assumption I believe to be void.

Herd behavior has had more influence on these games than individual deductive reasoning.

[Blackmage]

Day 1 Lynch, you get information via who voted, and better odds to hit mafia day 2.

Day 1 No lynch. You have no new information. Someone still dies in the night, which also gives no new information. Yes, you have an investigator. Guess what, Mafia can declare cop and name someone who is innocent. So what are you going to do day 2? Another thing to remember if you're relying on cops information, you have better odds losing your cop in the night than the day, because while you have 10 to choose from, mafia only has 7.

---------- Post added at 09:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:28 PM ----------

Quick question to Tom, as he left off his note to Rape. Was he actually bulletproof?

[Erdenay]

Day 1 Lynch, you get information via who voted, and better odds to hit mafia day 2.

Day 1 No lynch. You have no new information. Someone still dies in the night, which also gives no new information. Yes, you have an investigator. Guess what, Mafia can declare cop and name someone who is innocent. So what are you going to do day 2? Another thing to remember if you're relying on cops information, you have better odds losing your cop in the night than the day, because while you have 10 to choose from, mafia only has 7.

---------- Post added at 09:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:28 PM ----------

Quick question to Tom, as he left off his note to Rape. Was he actually bulletproof?

I did? Hm... I didn't do anything special with Rape, honestly. Also agreed with 100% what you said about no-lynch.

[Nemesis]

Still no one's said if they had fun.


Tom did you enjoy hosting it? You gonna do more?