Roman Scum: "The Mafia Game." (REGISTERED PLAYERS only here)

[brett friggin favre]

lets use our now, most reliable source of information. Blades sensor claim of two non town on the day 1 vote lynch.
When reviewing this list keep in mind that blade had not been converted yet and the first night was not accounted for, so there could only be 2 mafia and 1 cultist leader (nem at the time)

We know who voted
Mikey
Brett
Nem
Aco
Blade
Locust

The remaining players who did not vote but were alive

Chikun
Carm
Blackmage
Wolf

We know that one no mafia find was nemthenwolf
WE know that the second mafia find was a result of my ability deflecting to someone who did not vote. That means of those who did not vote its 50/50 that there mafia, since wolf died, that leaves Chikun, Blackmage, Carm. Sincle blades claim on blackmage happened day 3, the same day he started acting wierd and asked if all the role changes meant cult, we can not confirm his innocence.

So we have 3 to vote for, 2 are mafia, the other either town or cultist. Our odds are very high if we vote for only these three.
Carm
Chikun
Blackmage

good logic, and i didn't like blade's clearing of blackmage which gives him a slight edge in my head. personally im most worried about cult...if we killed 2 leaders, they could now have a 3rd and can still recruit. mafia, on the other hand, is static membership. they can't grow, and we can be basically sure there's just 2 of them. if we can eradicate cult, we can use what we know to take out the last 2 mafia, but if we can't eradicate the cult, they'll grow (as of tomorrow they'll only need 3 total) and get the win.

there's a reason why the mafiawiki page says: Some moderators allow Cultists to recruit players if the Cult Leader dies. However, this becomes completely impossible to balance, as there is virtually no chance of the Cult ever being completely wiped out.

[Carmichal]

I wish I was mafia I'd fuck you all up by now. Sadly I'm not.... so my loyalty is with the town, and I like winning to much to fuck this up.

I have to work a double tomorrow so I will get this out of the way...

vote blackmage...
Why? We all know why and at this point I would just be regurgitating words.

AND FUCK YOU BRETT!! I THOUGHT YOU LOVED ME AND KNEW ME ENOUGH TO KNOW I'M A GOOD PERSON! GOOD THINK YOU ARE TOWN OR I WOULD HAVE YOU HANGING FROM THE NOOSE BY NOW! lol....

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

good logic, and i didn't like blade's clearing of blackmage which gives him a slight edge in my head. personally im most worried about cult...if we killed 2 leaders, they could now have a 3rd and can still recruit. mafia, on the other hand, is static membership. they can't grow, and we can be basically sure there's just 2 of them. if we can eradicate cult, we can use what we know to take out the last 2 mafia, but if we can't eradicate the cult, they'll grow (as of tomorrow they'll only need 3 total) and get the win.

there's a reason why the mafiawiki page says: Some moderators allow Cultists to recruit players if the Cult Leader dies. However, this becomes completely impossible to balance, as there is virtually no chance of the Cult ever being completely wiped out.

you are right but based on the night scene, we can confirm that blade did not recruit anybody, as he tried to recruit a mafia and died. (blade was the intruder)
Knowing that no one was recruited last night when blade took on the role as cult leader, we now can confirm that there is only 1 cultist left. If we fuck up this lynch vote and hit a townie, town will lose.

---------- Post added at 02:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:00 AM ----------

Ill hole my vote to give blackmage a chance to defend, as all of you have given me that luxury.. this entire game.

[Blackmage]

Actually, there is a chance he could have recruited, if the target was a PGO.

Onto my defense. It sucks. Especially with what I'm about to be claiming. What I can do is help set up after my lynch. Dioscorides Town Doctor. Due to targeting Mikey last night, and it sounding like Blade got protected, I'm willing to say Mikey is Nexus. For the record, protected Aco day 1.

Not much else to say, feel free to lynch me, or wait for someone to counter claim doctor.

[brett friggin favre]

Actually, there is a chance he could have recruited, if the target was a PGO.

Onto my defense. It sucks. Especially with what I'm about to be claiming. What I can do is help set up after my lynch. Dioscorides Town Doctor. Due to targeting Mikey last night, and it sounding like Blade got protected, I'm willing to say Mikey is Nexus. For the record, protected Aco day 1.

Not much else to say, feel free to lynch me, or wait for someone to counter claim doctor.

why would you have targeted mikey?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

i beleive you but it is still possible you are now a cultist. Actually.. nvm it isnt possible. If blades last night as cop resulted in him confirming you as town, then that night you could not have been turned to cultist. The most recent night blade did not recruit somebody. So the cultist must be some one from the first night. Some one converted on the first night. Which also makes no sense because the cult leader pass is given to the longest living cult member after the original leader dies. Perhaps the cult threat is over? I dont see nem, wasting his cult leader ability on the first night though.


Blackmages role fits the game: Pedanius Dioscorides (Ancient Greek: Πεδάνιος Διοσκουρίδης; circa 40—90 AD) was a Greek physician, pharmacologist and botanist, the author of De Materia Medica—a 5-volume encyclopedia about herbal medicine and related medicinal substances (a pharmacopeia), that was widely read for more than 1,500 years.

---------- Post added at 02:31 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:30 AM ----------

Brett, perhaps it is because that would be the only way to confirm my claim as nexus.

[Blackmage]

Honestly? Pissed at all of you for voting for the person who gave the least information based upon what we had. List of people who would have given more information than Wolf: Me, Blade, Mikey, Chikun, possibly Carm. Wolf was also a known enemy, and therefore information while ALIVE. Only worse choice would have been you, Brett.

I'd sent it in before the lynch results were even out.

[brett friggin favre]

Brett, perhaps it is because that would be the only way to confirm my claim as nexus.

even so, the only way he'd know is if someone happened to target the same person that the protection happened to deflect onto...rather than actually using his power to protect someone of known value.

[Blackmage]

Mikey, my name doesn't prove anything, please don't pretend it does. This is what I was talking about easily duped. Just as Nem made a perfectly acceptable role from the right time period, how hard would it have been for me to wiki doctor 50AD?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

even so, the only way he'd know is if someone happened to target the same person that the protection happened to deflect onto...rather than actually using his power to protect someone of known value.

True but it appears blade attempted to recruit after his attempted murder, attempted to recruit a mafiascum. His attempt resulted in his death as cultist cannot recruit mafia with out dying. Im leaning towards chikun or carm on this one.

---------- Post added at 02:38 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:36 AM ----------

not hard at all but that does not defeat that fact that i think you are telling the truth. I also never trusted nem, because well.