Pokemon Mafia: Gotta Catch'em scum!

[Nemesis]

Nem:

Yeah, that's why I said it wasn't as easy, instead of impossible. They wouldn't be pushing for people, they'd just give us a name we didn't want. We actually could still get some information based upon the order people voted in.

Actually, if we REALLY wanted to do random, we'd pretty much have to schedule a time to livestream in front of at least 3 people. Even that could possibly be faked. But then, I'm paranoid. What it would do is remove hate votes. I could just see Nem "getting" 8 votes. I've said it before, I don't like random.

What:

One good thing is, either Taz will agree with him, and we realize they can't really give us more information, or Taz will disagree.

If taz agrees with mikey it doesn't rule out that they're the mafia.

Mikey's trying really hard to make it seem that he's VT and has no powers and should not be investigated. He's sitting out in the open and it just seems like such a bad move to paint such a large target so early in the game. I can't wrap my head around Mikey making such a bad call, can anyone else?

---------- Post added at 02:06 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:05 AM ----------

What's right. All it proves it that mikey and taz are on the same side.

If taz doesn't agree we lynch mikey. If he does agree should we not lynch one anyways to see if they're right? That way we at least know Taz is town for sure... I don't know here...

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

what, you are right. Taz can just agree but this is also tazs first mafia game. it really depends on you guys trusting me, we are VT masons. im asking the cop not to waste an investigate so that we can confirm more townies by day 2. With a lynch today and a night kill tommorow. we will be at 8 with 3 confirmed town. that means 2 of the 5 remaining players are mafia. those odds on day 2 are tremendous.

[What]

No lynch is not the answer here. I've been mulling some things over, we can through a vote at Brett, cause well, he could be a mafia again

Or we just kill mikey, if he is so sure that Taz wont die with him, then killing mikey can confirm taz as town, as we will have a confirmed townie. Though this is a risk.

If taz gets killed at night, well there is a good chance those two are gonna die tonight anyways since I'm betting they are linked, which would make a lynch vote for either one a bad move at this point, though who knows, maybe a lynch doesn't trigger those abilities.

As you can see, I'm still working on the logistics of the thing.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

also, when taz agrees that leaves two options, we are telling the truth or we are the mafia, why would the mafia reveal them selves so early in the game like that? My claim is solely for the benefit of the town, by raising the chance at lynching a mafia.

[Nemesis]

No lynch is not the answer here. I've been mulling some things over, we can through a vote at Brett, cause well, he could be a mafia again

Or we just kill mikey, if he is so sure that Taz wont die with him, then killing mikey can confirm taz as town, as we will have a confirmed townie. Though this is a risk.

If taz gets killed at night, well there is a good chance those two are gonna die tonight anyways since I'm betting they are linked, which would make a lynch vote for either one a bad move at this point, though who knows, maybe a lynch doesn't trigger those abilities.

As you can see, I'm still working on the logistics of the thing.

agree with no lynch.

Poor Brett, he's never gonna get a fair shake now.

If Mikey gets lynched then doc can protect taz, if there's no death then taz is innocent, if there is death Taz could be mafia.

---------- Post added at 02:24 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:24 AM ----------

also, when taz agrees that leaves two options, we are telling the truth or we are the mafia, why would the mafia reveal them selves so early in the game like that? My claim is solely for the benefit of the town, by raising the chance at lynching a mafia.

Easy, you think you're much smarter than you actually are, which isn't out of the norm for you.

[What]

what, you are right. Taz can just agree but this is also tazs first mafia game. it really depends on you guys trusting me, we are VT masons. im asking the cop not to waste an investigate so that we can confirm more townies by day 2. With a lynch today and a night kill tommorow. we will be at 8 with 3 confirmed town. that means 2 of the 5 remaining players are mafia. those odds on day 2 are tremendous.

Masons are Town-aligned players who know that they are Town and can speak to each other privately. Whether the Masons' ability to privately communicate can be used at any time or at Night only is up to the moderator's discretion. The number of Masons can vary from game to game, and it is not impossible for there to exist separate Mason groups within the same game.

Some moderators consider two Masons to be a roughly equivalent substitute for a Cop.

Thats from mafia scum, and while it seems to line up still means nothing at this point, since you can easily have read that.

Also you just went from two VT who were "Best Friends" to two masons.
Also, no reason to have claimed this so fucking early in the game, cause if you are masons, now your even bigger targets, and what does the brain trust of mikey and taz do to help the town?
So either you guys are mafia, or you are a total idiot for claiming this early, you should have waited and saw if either of your names came up, cause they might not have, no logical reason to claim this early other than to fuck with us, so still damn suspicious of you.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

what, you are trying really hard to justify lynching one of us. It may be best to wait for taz before you spend all this time rationalizing my fairly simple claim.

If i were mafia, why the hell would i reveal myself and compadre on day one?

[Blackmage]

What:

What it tells me is that they won't be claiming any new abilities, so we know they can't give us true information. Bulletproof because they have vig, survival because they protected, investigations, ect. All they can give is their observations. It's not useful information, but I'm trying to glean as much as I can from the mess we have.

If Taz disagrees, it's a whole new can of worms, which we'd have to deal with at that time.

Nem:

Here's how I look at his play. One day, Mikey will pull an incredibly devious move. Until that day, Mikey plays the game differently than I'm used to, in ways that give me headaches. I think Mikey was trying to give us information.

If we think we have enough townies to survive lynching a townie, it would give us a clear. We'd have some information on Taz in most cases, but we'd be giving the mafia a free turn. However, we also know we wouldn't hit a power role on accident.

We can make this more simple, either of you want to be lynched to save the other?

[What]

what, you are trying really hard to justify lynching one of us. It may be best to wait for taz before you spend all this time rationalizing my fairly simple claim.

If i were mafia, why the hell would i reveal myself and compadre on day one?

Taz doesn't do much to confirm anything, since he can read what you wrote.

Also, why would you reveal yourself and compadre on day one if you were both town?

---------- Post added at 01:31 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:28 AM ----------

more and more its making sense to confirm 1 town, since they aren't going to bring anything to the table by having no powers and talking to eachother, a scenario which can only be described as "The View:Shortbus addition"

I fail to see how this helps the town by you outing two townies on day fucking 1 with no provacation, cause now everyone knows you two likely have no other abilites, and can't do anything to help us besides pulling crap like this. If the mafia wants to go after a power role, and you are town, then you just narrowed their choices down dramatically dipshit

[Nemesis]

Taz doesn't do much to confirm anything, since he can read what you wrote.

Also, why would you reveal yourself and compadre on day one if you were both town?

---------- Post added at 01:31 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:28 AM ----------

more and more its making sense to confirm 1 town, since they aren't going to bring anything to the table by having no powers and talking to eachother, a scenario which can only be described as "The View:Shortbus addition"

I fail to see how this helps the town by you outing two townies on day fucking 1 with no provacation, cause now everyone knows you two likely have no other abilites, and can't do anything to help us besides pulling crap like this. If the mafia wants to go after a power role, and you are town, then you just narrowed their choices down dramatically dipshit

I say we keep Taz since he's new and isn't retarded.