Quote Originally Posted by What
I don't understand why so many people are like, well if BM turns up town we're in trouble.
Quote Originally Posted by What
with his death I know a mafia either way, regardless of what he turns up as.
That statement right there. As I've explained before, that's a problem. If you know a mafia either way, you can prove the same thing by lynching another player. Instead, you've run a "guilty until dead" crusade against me, never even considering another path. You're keeping everyone in the dark, expecting them to blindly follow your machinations. How many times have you insulted someone when they spoke against you?

As an example, if you kill me and you're mafia, you'd be down 1 or 2 townies after the night. 2 is more likely if the doctor chooses to protect you. Then Day 3 comes, you try to convince them that someone else is mafia, based upon some previously undisclosed information. If they happen to be townie too, hey look, 4 townies dead in 2 days, 2 mafia, 3 townies left for day 4, supposing nothing else happens. If nothing else DOES happens, you'll be dead Day 4, but then we'll have Mikey, someone else, and a mafia left. If Mikey trees or something, you win.