k... from the logs I have determined that he has never been banned from the pub

Also according to the logs he has been playing on the pub at least once a week for about 10 months. Also it can be estimated that he is slapped and beaconed about 99.9999999% more often than any other player. The logs of him being slapped or beaconed take up a massive % of the servers log. In fact I think that as much as 10% of the entire pub server log from almost a year is just logs of him having console commands run on him from slap and beacon to being kicked for high ping or reserved slot.

So now I am totally lost

Why exactly is he supposed to be banned I am really lost now