Supernatural Mafia

[acolyte_to_jippity]

I did not try to shift blame from anyone and that is what you insist upon... funny stuff. Also funny both sin and I provide scenarios that would benefit town regardless of outcome yet I am still suspect even after hard claim + actions.

ok guys. can i have a list of reasons why sin's plan to lynch him is bad? assume he's not a jester. it seems to give us a shitload of info.

[SCRIBBLE]

Please read any post prior to this one made by sin. Fuck you for not paying attention.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

Please read any post prior to this one made by sin. Fuck you for not paying attention.

i did. and it sounded like a good plan. hence why i asked for a reason why we haven't gone with it yet. fuck you.

[Nemesis]

i did. and it sounded like a good plan. hence why i asked for a reason why we haven't gone with it yet. fuck you.

The problem is how many people are agreeing with it, meaning some of them are mafia. That may be looking too much into it though.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

we are now officially on page 100.

[Nemesis]

we are now officially on page 100.

Your mother is on page 100.

[phil.™]

What am I supposed to say to it Scribble? "I'm not scum. Period."? That is what Phil did and acts like it clears him. It is possible that double voter is scum, though that is more rare then town sided. I have done my best this game for town. I don't see how you trying to shift the blame off of Phil when he clearly made a very pro mafia play does anything but implicate you. Thank you for letting us know who else is mafia if Phil comes up guilty.

I had claimed before Phil, both flavor and role to try to take pressure off the person I felt 80% sure of being Cop. After he did finally claim as I asked, I hard claimed. (though looking back, mikey is right. I shouldn't have let him force me so I could protect the cop). Also, my flavor is pretty positive. I don't really know how else to convince you.

What in the actual fuck part of "you seemed scummy at the time, i called you out; few other players called you out, and you fucking still dodged all question" not make me wonder or curious about you. I fucking said you claim first, then me. So don't give me that bs that you claimed first than me making me look scummy. That was the agreement. You really had nothing to hide, i mean being a double voter and all is not that great. It's good, but not great.

Are you illiterate or something? I'm making suggestions to help town, even willing to sacrifice myself so that town has a better chance of winning, and you still think i'm scum? You haven't done SHIT other than saying "lynch phil, why isnt he lynched yet". You sir, just went full retard.

[Sin]

The only problem I have with lynching Phil, is that IF Nemesis is lying, roleblocks Scribble, and kionay dies on Night 3. Scribble will look like a liar, as Nem will most likely say he roleblocked some other random person like "Mikey, because he's scummy".

Granted he COULD do the same if I were to be lynched, BUT we'd know for a fact that the Cop is not insane.

The situation really is between Scribble and Nem, because they're the ones with the contradicting abilities on Night 2. They're the ones we need to worry about come Day 4, if either of them are still alive.

One of them is lying, and I'm leaning towards Scribble, because a Godfather+Jailer role for Nem is OP as fuck and I wouldn't think that WHAT would put that in play.

[kionay]

What in the actual fuck part of "you seemed scummy at the time, i called you out; few other players called you out, and you fucking still dodged all question" not make me wonder or curious about you. I fucking said you claim first, then me. So don't give me that bs that you claimed first than me making me look scummy. That was the agreement. You really had nothing to hide, i mean being a double voter and all is not that great. It's good, but not great.

Are you illiterate or something? I'm making suggestions to help town, even willing to sacrifice myself so that town has a better chance of winning, and you still think i'm scum? You haven't done SHIT other than saying "lynch phil, why isnt he lynched yet". You sir, just went full retard.

at this point it's irrelevant if phil is scum or not (though i still think he is) because we need the info from his death, he's willing to die

so i think this matter is pretty well solved, let's get to lynching and move the fuck on so hopefully we don't have to reach page 200 -_-

[Sin]

I meant I'm leaning towards Nemesis as the one lying. He's most likely Godfather with no roleblocking power and has been lying since day 2 when he said he used his power on Aco.

Which is interesting, because gambling with an ability like that on a random player is suuuuper risky. So either Nemesis knew that Aco had no "ability" (because Aco is the Mafia Goon/Hitman) and was sure that Aco wouldn't put his claim on Blast.

In that scenario the past couple days' events make sense to me.

If you've all noticed we have no Crowley or Lucifer, prime candidates for a Godfather type role. Everyone claimed are basically minor roles aside from Dean, Sam, Castiel and Gabriel. It doesn't make sense to me, especially with the Flavor text.

I believe Nemesis and Aco are mafia, due to Nemesis' claim of "Jailer" and using his ability on Aco Night 1 because it was SAFE, and his contradiction with Scribble. Not to mention he's been playing scummy this entire game. I'm going to go with my original gut feeling from Day 1.

VOTE NEMESIS