Supernatural Mafia

[Passarelli]

Wouldn't it have been better to remove one of the unconfirmed VTs? That is what I was saying.

Nem had already said he was going to try to block the Scum rather then protect someone. Also:

...while another was taken aside for the night.

Seems to indicate a jailer, or at least a role blocker.

So unless you read something differently in the flavor, I'm pretty sure that helps clear him.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Wouldn't it have been better to remove one of the unconfirmed VTs? That is what I was saying.

Nem had already said he was going to try to block the Scum rather then protect someone. Also:



Seems to indicate a jailer, or at least a role blocker.

So unless you read something differently in the flavor, I'm pretty sure that helps clear him.

that could mean several things and though a jailer using his ability could be one, it dosnt make sense. The jailer dosnt move anyone or take them away ect.

[Passarelli]

With that, if the rest of you think that bit of flavor clears Nem, we should look at Aco. He has been very quiet then jumps on Nem. Thank you Mikey for making me go back and re-read.

- - - Updated - - -

What role do you think would make sense for that flavor? Jailkeeper is the only one I saw that would fit it, especially with the confirmed roles we have now.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

With that, if the rest of you think that bit of flavor clears Nem, we should look at Aco. He has been very quiet then jumps on Nem. Thank you Mikey for making me go back and re-read.

- - - Updated - - -

What role do you think would make sense for that flavor? Jailkeeper is the only one I saw that would fit it, especially with the confirmed roles we have now.

Well, it could be several roles that could fit in with what we can confirm from deaths.

First off, no one is confirmed, i dont know how many times i need to express this. Second off, the lists of claims cant be trusted as people could of easily lied about it, secondly, im sure people have lied about there roles and have mafia power roles. More times then not, roleblocker is mafia, nem isnt claiming roleblocker though. something most of you fail to understand with your posts. Roleblocker and jailer are two completely different roles.

- - - Updated - - -

taken aside for the night could mean several things like i said. It dosnt necessarily mean someone took someone aside (somthing the jailer dosnt even do in the first place) It could mean a player decided to use there role as such was not a part of the "flavor text" because they were "away" i.e. a tracker, watcher, voyeur. A town or mafia bus could have moved a player around with another, thus getting such flavor text ect. The possibilities are not limitless but are very large.

- - - Updated - - -

now, assuming everyone has told the truth, yes, it clears nem. However, not everyone could have told the truth. Actually, only under ONE circumstance could everyone actually be telling the truth and that is blade is holding us back from a town win. Again, that is extremely unlikley as someone is dying every night and no mafia have died.

[Passarelli]

Claimed roles is what I meant. Jailer is a combined roleblocker and protection.

The reason I thought that flavor might be clearing Nem is a jailer takes someone and puts them in jail. I see what you are saying kinda though. I could see a roleblocker use that text, but if he were mafia roleblocker, he likely would have been blocking Kionay.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Claimed roles is what I meant. Jailer is a combined roleblocker and protection.

The reason I thought that flavor might be clearing Nem is a jailer takes someone and puts them in jail. I see what you are saying kinda though. I could see a roleblocker use that text, but if he were mafia roleblocker, he likely would have been blocking Kionay.

Unless ofc, the mafia knew that every one apart from the godfather (who shows up inno) was flying low under the radar and were likley not to be the ones investigated.

Im not trying to discredit what you are saying but sin clearly had a plan and idea. His aim was at Nem and i never fully understood what exactly the plan entailed.
All i do know atm is that phil is still on my scum list for his behavior in D3 and even more so for trying to be the nice guy D4. I may be wrong but im sure kionay feels the same. I like to think of the cop as a leader role and would like to hear what kionay wants to do, who to lynch, ect.

- - - Updated - - -

id also like a list of people nem jailed every night. If it is at all possible to clear his name with out attempting to interpret flavor text, the answers may be with who he jailed.

[phil.™]

Curiosity though, why not investigate me last night kion? I was dead sure you would have investigated me.

[Wolfenstinger]

Vote Wolfenstinger

I'm moving forward with it but i'll check back tomorrow and see if anything changes my mind because either new info is put out, somebody slipped on ice, found a snake in their boot, poisoned the waterhole... etc...

Don't mind me.

[kionay]

Unless ofc, the mafia knew that every one apart from the godfather (who shows up inno) was flying low under the radar and were likley not to be the ones investigated.

Im not trying to discredit what you are saying but sin clearly had a plan and idea. His aim was at Nem and i never fully understood what exactly the plan entailed.
All i do know atm is that phil is still on my scum list for his behavior in D3 and even more so for trying to be the nice guy D4. I may be wrong but im sure kionay feels the same. I like to think of the cop as a leader role and would like to hear what kionay wants to do, who to lynch, ect.

- - - Updated - - -

id also like a list of people nem jailed every night. If it is at all possible to clear his name with out attempting to interpret flavor text, the answers may be with who he jailed.

i'm pretty scrub to be any kinda leader, but it seems to be we need to lynch blade or phil, or perhaps if someone has an epiphany and comes up with something we missed in the last hundred or so pages that can really incriminate someone

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Vote Wolfenstinger

I'm moving forward with it but i'll check back tomorrow and see if anything changes my mind because either new info is put out, somebody slipped on ice, found a snake in their boot, poisoned the waterhole... etc...

Don't mind me.

im am in favor of your plan, who would you target, out of curiosity? We would have more then enough votes to hit them, so i wouldnt worry about them not going along with the vote.