Supernatural Mafia

[Blackmage]

And now, the fun of playing with roles from a site that uses fairly open setups Onward!

Well, both scum and epic have werewolf. Scum's is "second mafia" or "cultfia", while epic's is... interesting to say the least. I've never played any epic with WW, so I'm just using its wiki page HERE.

Supposing it's "pure" Epic some points. First, Epic's win con is "Outnumber everyone else". Given his kill condition, and the general size of this game, I feel this makes it unlikely there was only one. Second the kill: he eats by claiming their role. Also, "Your devour bypasses protection, so you CAN eat anyone who is protected by vests or a Doctor/Nurse/Quack." He may not have tried to eat someone, or failed. The most likely target would have been Sin, so he may have felt Sin was lying. Given no one was revealed, at the very least any other possible ones seemed to have played it safe. "If role is guessed wrong, werewolf will be revealed to the town." Third: An important line, from the "playing against" section. "Always be wary of claiming. The wolf can tell if you're faking a claim (They know the roles) and any correct claims will have you devoured.". With flavour added, knowing roles can lead to being able to nom based on those two pieces of information.

So, what do we think WW does, and do we think they're still around? If we think one lurks among us, we have the sudden problem that forcing claims becomes even more dangerous. We still need what information we can get, so how hard do we push? Unless someone wants to claim Vig who popped Brett, we have to worry about at LEAST a SK, probably a mafia as well. Given the killer was more than human, if you ARE a vig who shot Brett, keep quiet if you're a human character.

The rest of my take on the night section:

There MAY have just been the one WW, he was "sitting by himself". However, from the wiki again, "Werewolves do not have meetings" so this may just mean that he chose to do nothing and had no one to talk to. Our deputy was probably scum's deputy, and we only have the cop left to investigate. There are a number of ways to read the protection part. One is two healers. Another is divine protection (Faith healer, or just an angel doctor) and physical means "bulletproof". Of course, that would also mean 3 night attacks but may suggest that werewolf does NOT just chew through everything.

Once this goes up, I'm starting my next post. Also, I keep reading stuffy as slutty, and it makes that scene strange.

[phil.™]

?_? What's a 3rd party werewolf?

[Old Bastard]

Well what I gather from the flavour of the kill scene is that the person that killed Brett is a demon nonetheless. They are the only ones who really use the ability to do shit to people without moving.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

Well what I gather from the flavour of the kill scene is that the person that killed Brett is a demon nonetheless. They are the only ones who really use the ability to do shit to people without moving.

along with angels, ghosts, Sam, and horsemen.

[Old Bastard]

Demon is the most likely of all in my opinion. Sam only had that ability for a little bit due to Yellow Eyes. Angels don't do it near as often. And it's been a long time since I watched that far back but I don't recall any horsemen doing that.

- - - Updated - - -

And ghosts, eh, kinda.

[Blackmage]

Technically, any of the 5 remaining voters could be the double voter. As What never releases the actual numbers, he may have just listed everyone who voted before he could end the day.

However, The most likely suspects are Sin, CyberWolf and Pass. If it's Sin, he's lied about his role since D1, and in D2, with the voting on Nem, if one more person had decided to push Nem to L-1, we would have ended the day right there. Pass has said he's hinted at his role, and I don't see doublevoter being the claim. Cyber also had voted for Nem, but with his claim not having been countered, I don't think he would have failed to mention a double voting. He could have, or pulled a risky soft claim of double voter. The other two are Mikey and Blade, who have voted for both lynchings.

Nem, did you jail Aco again? If it wasn't aco, that means that most likely we just have the mafia left to kill. Well, if you jailed Brett, that's important information as well, since that means the mafia beat your protection. It does sound like you didn't jail the cop either night, which is the main reason I'm not just asking for who you jailed.

Between Ludensky and Cain, even one episode characters are available. Also, more than one 3rd party is far from impossible.

I agree, any information from last night, or are we back to the finger pointing?

[acolyte_to_jippity]

I've already told you guys I can't confirm if he blocks me (though I appreciate the protection). Not sure why he would have blocked me again.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

I've already told you guys I can't confirm if he blocks me (though I appreciate the protection). Not sure why he would have blocked me again.

Maybe he likes you! If you were bl9cked by him and you tried to use an ability, you should get a message that says your ability didnt work.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

Maybe he likes you! If you were bl9cked by him and you tried to use an ability, you should get a message that says your ability didnt work.

i have zero abilities. What fucked this game up hard when he made roles/characters. Cain (first murderer, knight of hell, immortal, super powerful...) shouldn't be VT. And Chuck (fucking prophet of god) shouldn't be VT either. So there it is, i'm tired of this shit. i am Chuck, VT.

[kionay]

demon seems most likely to me, the lore twist of the roles is fun

werewolves in the show didn't usually run in packs (unlike vampires) and if i recall correctly they're always found one by one (with that one exception of the video recording kids)

it's late, i'll be back on tomorrow morning