Blackmage, is there a reason you haven't voted at all yet? Also, keep in mind that I didn't want to use obvious clue is obvious as OB did. That one is likely a Red Herring. You are likely looking in the right spot, but use a little more lateral thinking. Not much, but a little.

I'm pretty sure Cyber was telling the truth, judging from his reaction to the whole episode.

Sin could have been lying unless someone has investigated him already. Blade is still fishy, as are Phil and Scrib. Mikey--well, you know how I feel. ^_^

I'll be on in a couple hours to vote once everyone has gotten to say their piece.