Best Player: Blade- though he should have been killed and called out multiple times, his 3rd party claim, once believed, was quit good.
Worst Player: Acolyte- Never questioned anyone’s claim and took every statement a player made for the absolute truth. Combined with not attracting the mafia’s attention, just terrible.
Biggest Derp Award: Tie between Kionay and Nemesis- Kionay wanted to investigate Locust after he had been lynched, nuff said. Nemesis decided to make up a rule regarding roleblocking instead of actually looking it up. This put the town way behind, though they are to be blamed for not bothering to look up the rule as well and instead take another players word for it.
Close but no Cigar: Passarelli- new player playing a role that requires a lot of persuasion to win, one more day and he probably would have done it, though it was disturbing he didn’t call out Blade’s 3rd party claim.
Overall, the town did not play this one great, they had tons of advantages over the mafia, but were too easily persuaded to keep killing their own. Had more of you focused on the actual game instead of trying to over think or meta game this stuff, you would have won. Also, as I stated in the first post, this was a flavor game, not based on a particular plot or season. It is not an RPG, of course demons, werewolves, angels, and the like can’t be killed by a gun or lynching, but this is a mafiawars game flavored by Supernatural, so everyone complaining that X person should have powers is missing the point. Regardless of what anyone says, this is the longest and most post producing game yet played on IBIS, and I label it a success.