Supernatural Mafia

[Blackmage]

Sin: Mass claiming, even flavour claiming due to the closed environment we have, shrinks the guessing games significantly for both sides. We have to figure out who makes the worst claim, while we make characters such as Sam, Dean, Bobby and Cas pretty much instant targets. Depending on who all is shown, we might lose our healer night one, and then we better believe we can quickly figure out who the scum are fast. Your claim of Rufus VT actually may have made that harder, because it shows what kind of character is relegated to being a VT. We also have the problem that almost any hunter could be PGO or Macho. I do agree mass claiming is an option, I'm not sure I like having it come from someone who claimed VT.

While what he did may have been scummy or hurtful, unless we think he's lying or going to hurt us more, I don't think it would be worth it to lynch him. All the information we'd get currently is "who is willing to wagon a VT". At the very least, Nem, could you explain how lynching him is better than just going NL? Note: "he's black" isn't sufficient.

Dick Roman is from Season 7, which I won't be starting till today. Castiel could be good, evil, VT, 3rd party, god, lyncher going after Raphael, or what have you, depending on WHICH version we are working with. However, I'm leaning towards agreeing with OB. We have similar issues with characters such as Anna, Crowley, Ruby(if you REALLY want to stretch things), Death, and the list goes on and on in this show. We can make educated guesses, if they show up, but we may have some surprises.

Beyond that, seems everyone is waiting for Stan.

[Sin]

that's about the scummiest thing i've ever heard without actually claiming mafia. ffs, if people give character names, it'll flat-out give away faction and/or power roles. might not tell what the roles are, but it'll absolutely give away their existence.

example, if someone claims Bobby, they have a role. If someone claims...idk, Emily (from s1 e11) then they're not going to be a power role.

Wasn't Bobby the guy my character trained and then turned evil and killed me? Why would they have a role, and why WOULDN'T they be mafia? Granted it's up to the mods who has what roles and side on which faction. I only stated that Castiel is a Serial Killer because in the wiki I read of him he's emotionless and kills innocents if necessary.

And Blackmage what does Dick Roman being in season 7 have anything to do with anything? One of his "quotables" was in the flavor text. Or does flavor text have nothing to do with mafia games anymore?

Bottom line is I'm trying to get discussion going, which kind of worked for a minute, but I still say Nem is a cumdumpster for trying to wagon a VT lynch.

- - - Updated - - -

I don't have a useful role except the fact that at least one Townie is needed alive to win the game. And since I'm a VT mafia wouldn't waste their NK on me unless they're stupid.

[kionay]

are there spoiler tags? i'd like to post some spoilers the wiki might not, to clarify how castiel can be VT, then SK, then VT again... :-/

then again i'm not caught up with the series, gettin' there, but not yet :-/

[Passarelli]

Keep this one short and sweet since I have to head out again.

Vote Nemesis

He has been the scummiest person so far. If someone else acts even scummier, I will likely swap to them when I get home.