Supernatural Mafia

[phil.™]

I have honestly no idea who to vote for, as we have been going back and forth on the same idea and concept for the past 20 pages.
We need a deadline, to get shit moving. I suggest What gives us a deadline.

[Sin]

I mean lying about Roleblocking Scribs in Night 2.

[Nemesis]

I mean lying about Roleblocking Scribs in Night 2.

Roleblocked the shit out of him. He was all like, "Yo, can I has this action?" and I was all, "Noze-way Blackie!"

Tru stry.

[Sin]

Everyone Vote scribble. If he's legit, Nem is lying and he can get lynched tomorrow.

But it also means Kionay is dead no matter what.

- - - Updated - - -

Lynching Phil gives us nothing to go off of tomorrow.

[phil.™]

Everyone Vote scribble. If he's legit, Nem is lying and he can get lynched tomorrow.

But it also means Kionay is dead no matter what.

- - - Updated - - -

Lynching Phil gives us nothing to go off of tomorrow.

Why would lynching me give us nothing for tomorrow?
Scribbs protects kion, and kion investigates someone else, Mikey or Pass or whoever.

[Sin]

Because the issue we're facing is the Nem vs. Scribs scenario. Lynching you will only tell us if you're town/mafia like anyone else, except the main issue at hand will still be up in the air. We'd get no definitive answer, and only entertain the possibility of them contradicting each other AGAIN, leaving us in the same situation we're in today.

[Nemesis]

And there is also the chance that it's Blackmage, Mikey, and Blade and that Scribble, Phil, and Sin are just the worst possible players to ever join a mafia game.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Not really. If scribbs is being honest, he will likley die protecting the cop and that incriminates nem equal to every other plan you had. Any 4 of you has the same outcome pretty much.

[Sin]

In the best case scenario:

- Scribble dies protecting Kionay
- Kionay is able to investigate Mikey/Blackmage/ect...
- Nemesis is able to potentially block the mafia hitman if he guesses correctly, meaning no one will die

And we'd have a happy little adventure figuring out who the other mafia members are.

- - - Updated - - -

But that can't possibly happen because EITHER NEM OR SCRIBS IS LYING!

[Nemesis]

In the best case scenario:

- Scribble dies protecting Kionay
- Kionay is able to investigate Mikey/Blackmage/ect...
- Nemesis is able to potentially block the mafia hitman if he guesses correctly, meaning no one will die

And we'd have a happy little adventure figuring out who the other mafia members are.

- - - Updated - - -

But that can't possibly happen because EITHER NEM OR SCRIBS IS LYING!

There is a scenario where both me and Scrib are Town but I'm not sure if I'm allowed to discuss it because it would be calling out the mod as terrible and we all know how this mod gets when you mention him (i.e. Sandy)