
Originally Posted by
Sin
The only problem I have with lynching Phil, is that IF Nemesis is lying, roleblocks Scribble, and kionay dies on Night 3. Scribble will look like a liar, as Nem will most likely say he roleblocked some other random person like "Mikey, because he's scummy".
Granted he COULD do the same if I were to be lynched, BUT we'd know for a fact that the Cop is not insane.
The situation really is between Scribble and Nem, because they're the ones with the contradicting abilities on Night 2. They're the ones we need to worry about come Day 4, if either of them are still alive.
One of them is lying, and I'm leaning towards Scribble, because a Godfather+Jailer role for Nem is OP as fuck and I wouldn't think that WHAT would put that in play.