Supernatural Mafia

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Players currently Alive : Kionay(cup), Passarelli(doublevooter), Cyber[Me] (hunter?), Aco(vt/mafia?), Blackmage (guilty/mafia), Blade(3rd Party survivor?), Mikey(VT/possible GF?)

Players we confirmed : Sin (VT), Nemesis (Town Cockblocker), Old Bastid (Town Faith Healer), Phil (VT), Stan (Town Cop), Brett (3rd Party Werewolf), Scribble (Town Bodyguard), Locust (VT)


Sounds bout right.... right?

The only confirmed person we have alive is Kion, he claims on who he investigated have proven correct with sin and nems deaths. Additionally, anyone apart from him could be GF as well.

- - - Updated - - -

and everyone apart from kion could also be mafia.

[Passarelli]

We should lynch blackmage then. We should also look at Aco again tomorrow.

Tomorrow will likely be 2 mafia left with 5 alive. Blade, I hope you keep siding with town! Kionay, make your investigation tonight count again, they will likely come after me.

I'm going to go back through and see if I can spot Blackmage trying subtly protect anyone or steer the conversation away from anyone in his walls of info.

- - - Updated - - -

Just from the list of players, I think it is likely Aco is the killer and mikey is the godfather. Lets see if blackmage gave us any evidence on that front.

[kionay]

We should lynch blackmage then. We should also look at Aco again tomorrow.

Tomorrow will likely be 2 mafia left with 5 alive. Blade, I hope you keep siding with town! Kionay, make your investigation tonight count again, they will likely come after me.

I'm going to go back through and see if I can spot Blackmage trying subtly protect anyone or steer the conversation away from anyone in his walls of info.

- - - Updated - - -

Just from the list of players, I think it is likely Aco is the killer and mikey is the godfather. Lets see if blackmage gave us any evidence on that front.

assuming i make it tonight, i mean with no sort of protection left i'm probably going to get skullfucked tonight :C

[Blackmage]

There's always this.

Or more seriously, the only real thing of use to say is, what roles do we think the mafia have? It probably isn't defensive. The killing roles required them to be outted truly, or day protection. Probably wasn't roleblocker, as the cop is alive and working. Strongman or second kill, again, cop is alive and no extra people are left. The only real things left would be vote related or falsifying. The only vote relating person is Pass. I voted Sin without hammering, and Blade voted to hammer, proving my vote is worth 1 vote. Which means they probably have some way of falsifying reports. They were trying to divide and conquer. However, it's LYLO, so if you decide to lynch me, so be it. I will stay back and speak if requested, otherwise, see you on the other side.

Side note: I was mostly wrong about Nem. However, out of 4 nights, he neither role blocked a killer or protected a target. Neat.

[Wolfenstinger]

There's always this.

Or more seriously, the only real thing of use to say is, what roles do we think the mafia have? It probably isn't defensive. The killing roles required them to be outted truly, or day protection. Probably wasn't roleblocker, as the cop is alive and working. Strongman or second kill, again, cop is alive and no extra people are left. The only real things left would be vote related or falsifying. The only vote relating person is Pass. I voted Sin without hammering, and Blade voted to hammer, proving my vote is worth 1 vote. Which means they probably have some way of falsifying reports. They were trying to divide and conquer. However, it's LYLO, so if you decide to lynch me, so be it. I will stay back and speak if requested, otherwise, see you on the other side.

Side note: I was mostly wrong about Nem. However, out of 4 nights, he neither role blocked a killer or protected a target. Neat.

/offtopic
YOU WILL TELL US THE KRABBY PATTY SECRET FORMULA
/ontopic

Anyways... If say I did happen to die... How much were you hoping I would just shoot a inno and not a mafia member? Because honestly, I was gonna shoot you yesterday had I been lynched. Now that there's confirmation of what you are, there's no point.

[BladeTwinSwords]

We should lynch blackmage then. We should also look at Aco again tomorrow.

Tomorrow will likely be 2 mafia left with 5 alive. Blade, I hope you keep siding with town! Kionay, make your investigation tonight count again, they will likely come after me.

I'm going to go back through and see if I can spot Blackmage trying subtly protect anyone or steer the conversation away from anyone in his walls of info.

- - - Updated - - -

Just from the list of players, I think it is likely Aco is the killer and mikey is the godfather. Lets see if blackmage gave us any evidence on that front.

Well at this point, I can either side with town, which benefits me, or side with mafia which still has a chance to backfire.

As a Survivor, I simply have to stay alive. Most Survivors do not last as long as I do.

This is towns decision on who to lynch, not mine. Whoever you all vote for, I will support you, including voting for myself if I have to.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

We should lynch blackmage then. We should also look at Aco again tomorrow.

Tomorrow will likely be 2 mafia left with 5 alive. Blade, I hope you keep siding with town! Kionay, make your investigation tonight count again, they will likely come after me.

I'm going to go back through and see if I can spot Blackmage trying subtly protect anyone or steer the conversation away from anyone in his walls of info.

- - - Updated - - -

Just from the list of players, I think it is likely Aco is the killer and mikey is the godfather. Lets see if blackmage gave us any evidence on that front.

why?
**

[Passarelli]

Kionay, at this point I'm pretty sure I am as likely to die as you so that the mafia can end this sooner (especially if there is only a Godfather left).

How many scum do you guys think is left?

We had 15 people to start and 2 confirmed 3rd parties. If we have 2 mafia total that means town would make up 73% of the starting group and mafia would have 13%. If we have 3 mafia, town would make up 66% and Mafia would be 20%.

I'm leaning for 3 members because Blackmage was role blocked and the kill still went through. (only if the Godfather can not make a kill unless all other scum is dead. I haven't been able to find this in the rules at all. The only thing I spotted where one person on scum made kills was poisoner. Please point out what I'm missing in the wiki so I can play this game better ^_^)

- - - Updated - - -

why?
**

Do you think there are 2 or 3 scum in this game?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Kionay, at this point I'm pretty sure I am as likely to die as you so that the mafia can end this sooner (especially if there is only a Godfather left).

How many scum do you guys think is left?

We had 15 people to start and 2 confirmed 3rd parties. If we have 2 mafia total that means town would make up 73% of the starting group and mafia would have 13%. If we have 3 mafia, town would make up 66% and Mafia would be 20%.

I'm leaning for 3 members because Blackmage was role blocked and the kill still went through. (only if the Godfather can not make a kill unless all other scum is dead. I haven't been able to find this in the rules at all. The only thing I spotted where one person on scum made kills was poisoner. Please point out what I'm missing in the wiki so I can play this game better ^_^)

Im going to break this down so that you may understand it to the best of your ability....

Town Power Roles - 7

Cop
Doc
Body Guard
Double Voter
Jailer
Deputy
Hunter

Third Party - 2
Werewolf
Survivour

Vanilla Townies - 5

Mafia - 3
Goon
God Father
Unknown

Total = 17 Assigned roles

How might that be possible you ask?
17 assigned roles = two people are lying, those two people cant be dead. So its 2 people who are alive, excluding blackmage. This is how i came up with there being 3 mafia.

You are suggesting that the two people left lying are myself and aco.. which leaves only 3 actual VT's. If you honestly believe that then i suggest you do more research on how to balance a basic game that avoids role madness. Only 3 VT's with 7 town power roles vs 5 anti town roles? If that is the case, which it is not... the mod would not be modding again, at least not here. As im sure nem would give them an actual earful.

- - - Updated - - -

as i stated several handfuls of pages back, i dont think it is hard to claim given the theme. The cast is damn near endless and the role is easier to fake due to the amount of newer players here in this game who may not fully understand balancing.

- - - Updated - - -

oh, to answer your question you added. I think there is 3. Given the reasons i posted. I also think that one of the power role claims is lying.

- - - Updated - - -

and that aside from blackmage, our best shot at this point (assuming kion kicks the bucket tonight) is to push aco.

- - - Updated - - -

time for bed now, work in the morning.

[Passarelli]

I'm glad to see you put it so well. Now by that logic, I can not be mafia or else we would be end gamed. If there were 3 mafia and I were the third there would be 4 votes controlled by Scum.

That said, I think we should lynch Blackmage today and let Kionay inspect whomever. There will be 5 of us left tomorrow. If I die, Kionay will likely pick out the Scum. If not, I trust Wolf to hunt down the truth.