I dont see why the gem giver wouldnt reveal. As I laid out, he can pretty much narrow it down to 2-3 people, and its not like he has a power to confirm anyone, its just a role, it appears, to give something to someone and thereby confirm themself as town, the only reason it works for whoever got a gem last night is that it looks like caitlyn got a gem last night and that person should pretty much be the cop, hence those 2 are cleared, blade/phil are clear, so thats 4 out of nine, I would like to think I have been cleared at this point, thats 5, if the cop got an innocent hit on someone alive who isnt any of those people, thats 6, Locust should be scum, so that would have 7 out of 9 essentially cleared.

- - - Updated - - -

eh not 7 cleared, 7 identified, obviously scum is not a clear.

- - - Updated - - -

I mean yes the gem fgiver would essentially out teh cop, so maybe let them decide if they come forward, ideally if they have usuable info, it appears they investigated mikey last night, so that was a bust, but night 1 is still a possibility.

- - - Updated - - -

but if cop comes forward so should the gem giver, as i said to narrow down the suspect pool.

- - - Updated - - -

this is also all provided that the first person in the scene, who checked out mikey, and got a gem, is caitlyn, which i think is what wolf was saying, likely due to her love of tea?

- - - Updated - - -

And the gem giver/cop will defintly want/need to speak up the next day if they are still alive, at that point there will be like 7 or less people remaining, and between the cop, giver, and masons, thats 4 people. Also if gem giver is a thing, trying to think of the mafia scum equivilent. I think its friendly neighbor.