Beginner Mafia Game #1

[phil.™]

Nobody vote the last vote for fallen yet. We need a game plan, and I think I may have one. I am driving at the moment, and will post when I get to work.

Whoever votes the final vote for fallen before I state my game plan, I will assume you are mafia getting the lynch over with.

[hoshiro-]

So for not posting good reasons for my votes i am possibly scum yet some of you do the same thing yet you have played a lot more games then me with this being my 1st time playing.

This leads me to believe you are either doing this on purpose to get rid of someone who hasn't played a game like this before or you're mafia and taking out the least experienced players first who could be crucial to towns victory later on. At this point the game is turned into anything a player doesn't do or does do is scummy and is likely to get x player lynched even though they could have useful information for the town. Also Phil thanks for the deadline due to my timezone being GMT+1.
Anyway at this point my top 2 suspicious players are Hoshiro jumping votes like i was doing at the being even though he has player a game or two more than me he should know better in my opinion. Now for my 2nd is assassin is now going with little to no reason with his votes like i did earlier in the game but assassin should be make less mistakes with having played this game before and those games weren't set up like this with just beginners. so these players should have gained a better grasp at how to player from people like what or cyber by looking at there posts or play styles to see how they could improve. This is due to you both being in the LoL game that cyber made.

Just woke up to post this might post later if i survive.

not true about the first reason bro, this is only my second time playing and i was the first one out my last game so im still a noob too

[phil.™]

SORRY. WALL OF TEXT COMING

Okay, so here is my proposition. Either someone has another game plan, or we can try and stick with this one.

At this point the game is turned into anything a player doesn't do or does do is scummy and is likely to get x player lynched even though they could have useful information for the town.

Are you soft claiming that you have a power role? What useful information could you possibly provide for us as a town? Your longest post was your two suspicion on hosh and ass, and that's after being put into a corner from a lynch.

Sorry fallen, you will die this game. You will either be lynched today, killed tonight or lynched tomorrow; this is what I propose.

The reason why I am hesitant to vote fallen is because of the quote listed above. He may very well have a power role, seeing that town will never get any useful information at night.
A) We vote lynch fallen Day 1, and gamble if he is a power role. If he's town, then it was bound to happen sooner or later (not to him but another town). If he is scum, well done whoever started the lynch train.
B) We do not vote lynch him, either vote someone else suspicious, or possibly vote a no-lynch. (Which I am not for still), we can do the following for the night.
i) If we do not vote lynch fallen now, there's a good chance mafia will target him (as he is potential power role).
ii) If you are in fact the cop, I do ask the doctor or healer (if we have one) to protect fallen. Next day, if fallen is telling the truth, the doctor or healer or whatever should be dead, and fallen better have some information for us next day. If he does not have any information for us, mafia luckily targeted the doctor or whatever, and fallen is lying and is scum. We vote lynch him next day.
iii) If you are in fact the doctor, protect yourself. This will buy the cop 1 day (if we even have a cop). If nobody dies at night, fallen is our doctor, and is telling the truth. He is crossed off our list from the lynch vote, and mafia will target him the following night, again buying the cop or sheriff (if we have one) another night.
iv) If some random dies, fallen is possibly lying and we vote lynch him next day.

[Assassin]

Actually Fallen this is only my 3rd game (4th if you count the other current game going).

[Trigger Unhappy]

3rd game here

[minjae]

Hence a beginner game LOL.
Most, almost all of us don't have much experience, except the few.

Yeah, it definitely seems like he's soft claiming a power role from what he said.
And/or he's just claiming he has information? Like a watcher of some sort. Which I doubt because this game is supposed to be a simple set up.
I may change my lynch vote depending on how the night goes, and maybe even before that. What phil said does make sense in his "wall of text" (which is really nothing compared to some others...lol)

What do you guys think? We lynch fallen? OR lynch/no lynch someone else suspicious, and then wait to see what happens at night.

- - - Updated - - -

And of course the fact he could be mafia as well. Which is obviously why we could/would be lynching him.

[hoshiro-]

I'm not changing my votes anymore so it's up to you guys to decide. For now I'm gonna disappear until you guys decide on something.

[Passarelli]

SORRY. WALL OF TEXT COMING

ii) If you are in fact the cop, I do ask the doctor or healer (if we have one) to protect fallen. Next day, if fallen is telling the truth, the doctor or healer or whatever should be dead, and fallen better have some information for us next day. If he does not have any information for us, mafia luckily targeted the doctor or whatever, and fallen is lying and is scum. We vote lynch him next day.

Phil, I expected you to at least read the wiki ; p

Doctors are not allowed to self-target.

[Assassin]

Lets just get this rolling, someone else vote fallen so we can see where the chips land.

[phil.™]

Phil, I expected you to at least read the wiki ; p

Totally forgot, and i actually read that this morning too.
iii) If fallen is doctor, then atleast we didn't lynch him.

Lets just get this rolling, someone else vote fallen so we can see where the chips land.

Without a game plan?