Beginner Mafia Game #1

[phil.™]

Also Phil is that the 3rd or 4th player that you have voted for Day 1?

Yes, correct. 4th vote.
1st on hosh because he is the new brett.
2nd on min because he lied.
3rd on ass because voting a no lynch to lynch is scummy
4th on you because inactivity.

[Trigger Unhappy]

Shall I post more inane comments? Pass I think would agree with me... lynching for inactivity has hurt town in the past. I havent been extremely involved but if people want I can start posting random lynch/no lynch/unvote posts like others have been doing. The only reason im posting now is that i finally got a chance to break for lunch. Fuck salary...

[Passarelli]

At least 1 of the mafia has likely voted in the 4 person wagons. Otherwise, scum likely would have hammered it.

Right now the person I suspect the most is Fallen. He has said very little other then voting. He has been on both lynch wagons of 4 people and gets off the wagon gets off track.

Phil was the first unvote when there were 4 people on the wagon for Hosh, which makes me think that he isn't scum.

Trig, to answer your question: Yes, I do agree with you. Lynching someone for inactivity is always a bad idea. The first reason is that there are traditionally roles that want to sit back and watch and stay out of the crosshairs so they aren't forced to claim (Cop and Doctor both usually do this on day 1). The second reason is that it comes dangerously close to a policy lynch which again, is a horrible idea.

[Trigger Unhappy]

At least 1 of the mafia has likely voted in the 4 person wagons. Otherwise, scum likely would have hammered it.

Right now the person I suspect the most is Fallen. He has said very little other then voting. He has been on both lynch wagons of 4 people and gets off the wagon gets off track.

Phil was the first unvote when there were 4 people on the wagon for Hosh, which makes me think that he isn't scum.

Trig, to answer your question: Yes, I do agree with you. Lynching someone for inactivity is always a bad idea. The first reason is that there are traditionally roles that want to sit back and watch and stay out of the crosshairs so they aren't forced to claim (Cop and Doctor both usually do this on day 1). The second reason is that it comes dangerously close to a policy lynch which again, is a horrible idea.

I actually just re-read everything and agree with Pass. If you look back at everyones posts (which i just did) Fallen has done nothing except vote randomly, unvote, or say that he is waiting to see what everyone else does. That isn't overtly scummy, but he seems to be posting just enough to seem active.

My first inclination on certain people:

Pass : seems to be active and forthcoming with information. Not afraid to vote for a no lynch even though we have seen in the past that that can be detrimental to town. Made a good case for no lynch.

Phil : Seems to be equally active as pass. 4th vote to lynch someone and 3rd bandwagon jump. Suspicious but not overtly so.

Minjae : Hasn't posted anything concrete. Mostly posting for the sake of posting. Scummy ?

Assassin : I voted Assassin because one of his posts hit me as strange. Re-reading i might remove this.

Fallen: Calls people inactive but hasnt been active himself. Only posts have been lynch/nolynch or commenting about how he will vote based on how everyone else does. Isn't making decisions for himself but following group. Slightly suspicious.

[phil.™]

I actually just re-read everything and agree with Pass. If you look back at everyones posts (which i just did) Fallen has done nothing except vote randomly, unvote, or say that he is waiting to see what everyone else does. That isn't overtly scummy, but he seems to be posting just enough to seem active.

My first inclination on certain people:

Pass : seems to be active and forthcoming with information. Not afraid to vote for a no lynch even though we have seen in the past that that can be detrimental to town. Made a good case for no lynch.

Phil : Seems to be equally active as pass. 4th vote to lynch someone and 3rd bandwagon jump. Suspicious but not overtly so.

Minjae : Hasn't posted anything concrete. Mostly posting for the sake of posting. Scummy ?

Assassin : I voted Assassin because one of his posts hit me as strange. Re-reading i might remove this.

Fallen: Calls people inactive but hasnt been active himself. Only posts have been lynch/nolynch or commenting about how he will vote based on how everyone else does. Isn't making decisions for himself but following group. Slightly suspicious.

And your view on hosh and wolf?

[Trigger Unhappy]

And your view on hosh and wolf?

Hosh I think now is town. he hasnt been giving a ton of information but then again he is new to the game.

Wolf - When Hosh was being voted by the bandwagon, Wolf didnt join in. He actually made a comment that it seemed wrong. He agreed with Pass idea of no lynch after the case was made and so feel less suspicious of him than most people.

[TheFallen927]

Pass i don't really mind being a suspect but the reason i'm posting a lot is due to the fact i can't think of things to make a longer post at the time. Also making long posts is something i don't do a lot unless i find the topic interesting enough or is important i will make a longer post for it.

Concerning this game i think that your reasoning for a no lynch is good and would increase the chances of the cop finding mafia if there is an investigation role in-game this would also prolong the game and could allow for that player to waste there power on someone note important if there persuaded by others to do that. I wont change my vote to that option though

Also if you want me to be more active jut say so though i wont be on in 1 hour due to it being 10:35 pm right now.

[Wolfenstinger]

I still feel that killing off Hoshiro is going to be wrong at the moment. Gut feeling atm; may change after this day.

[Passarelli]

Pass i don't really mind being a suspect but the reason i'm posting a lot is due to the fact i can't think of things to make a longer post at the time. Also making long posts is something i don't do a lot unless i find the topic interesting enough or is important i will make a longer post for it.

Concerning this game i think that your reasoning for a no lynch is good and would increase the chances of the cop finding mafia if there is an investigation role in-game this would also prolong the game and could allow for that player to waste there power on someone note important if there persuaded by others to do that. I wont change my vote to that option though

Also if you want me to be more active jut say so though i wont be on in 1 hour due to it being 10:35 pm right now.

It wasn't so much that you haven't been active enough, it has more to do with how you have been voting and when you vote and unvote. coupled with the fact that I see it as unlikely that scum have abstained from voting when they could have hammered two different people. Adding a couple sentences as to the reasoning behind your post always helps and gives the person in question a chance to reason with you ^_^

- - - Updated - - -

Also, thanks for the reply! I still think we should hold off for the day--I just find you a bit more suspicious then anyone else at the moment. Depending on how the votes go and who scum kills that should solidify a couple of my suspicions.

[TheFallen927]

Thanks for the advice at the end of your post i will do that more often when i make other votes.