Mafia Game: The Donner Party

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

I know, lol.

- - - Updated - - -


I guess. Lynching town is still counter-productive though.

Why have you played so scummy up until now?
If you really are town.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

it is in fact a lynch.........

- - - Updated - - -

wait what?

My vote was L-1 tho

- - - Updated - - -

Current Vote Count:
Zambi - 6 Votes (1 more)
Assassin - 3 Votes (4 more)
Blade - 1 Vote (6 more)

yea this was on page 28 and no one unvoted zambi since this page.

[Passarelli]

I've color coded how suspicious I am of people for everyone (except Mikey's) enjoyment.

1. Phil - Claimed VT. Most likely correct, but he still smells.
2. Assassin - Claimed Town (whoopie!). Pretty suspicious overall.
3. Minjae - Very suspicious. Most likely scum. Has been way too quiet.
4. Sin - Most likely town sided. SK is possible but unlikely.
5. Mikey - Townie.
6. Scribble - Very suspect. He was silent except for votes until Phil and Zambi claimed then tried to move the conversation away from them. When compared to the previous game, it is neigh identical. 90% sure either Mafia or SK.
7.Trigger Unhappy - Slightly suspicious. Hasn't said anything very useful but seems town sided.
8. Blade - Very suspect. Moved votes around willy nilly.
10. I'm a zambi - Claimed VT. Probably correct but he could be SK or intentionally trolling his partner as Scum.
11. Cyber - Most likely town.
12. Hosh - Very suspicious. Most likely scum. Has been way too quiet.

I have thoughts on who our power roles could be (one or two of them are 50/50 either scum or power role) but I chose not to list that as I don't want them targeted at night.

I still think our best bet would be to vote Phil or Zambi as they are the two that claimed roles. One or both could be lying, we wouldn't hit a power role, and we would not increase the chances of a power role getting hit at night any further then they already are. Since I trust Phil much more at the moment, that is why I removed my vote for him. He still smells though.

The only other people I would be willing to vote right now is Scribble and possibly Blade.

[Trigger Unhappy]

I've color coded how suspicious I am of people for everyone (except Mikey's) enjoyment.

1. Phil - Claimed VT. Most likely correct, but he still smells.
2. Assassin - Claimed Town (whoopie!). Pretty suspicious overall.
3. Minjae - Very suspicious. Most likely scum. Has been way too quiet.
4. Sin - Most likely town sided. SK is possible but unlikely.
5. Mikey - Townie.
6. Scribble - Very suspect. He was silent except for votes until Phil and Zambi claimed then tried to move the conversation away from them. When compared to the previous game, it is neigh identical. 90% sure either Mafia or SK.
7.Trigger Unhappy - Slightly suspicious. Hasn't said anything very useful but seems town sided.
8. Blade - Very suspect. Moved votes around willy nilly.
10. I'm a zambi - Claimed VT. Probably correct but he could be SK or intentionally trolling his partner as Scum.
11. Cyber - Most likely town.
12. Hosh - Very suspicious. Most likely scum. Has been way too quiet.

I have thoughts on who our power roles could be (one or two of them are 50/50 either scum or power role) but I chose not to list that as I don't want them targeted at night.

I still think our best bet would be to vote Phil or Zambi as they are the two that claimed roles. One or both could be lying, we wouldn't hit a power role, and we would not increase the chances of a power role getting hit at night any further then they already are. Since I trust Phil much more at the moment, that is why I removed my vote for him. He still smells though.

The only other people I would be willing to vote right now is Scribble and possibly Blade.

Alright here is my list (not color coded)
1. Phil - Close to being lynched earlier. Was ok with being sacrificed ( claimed VT) 95% sure he is VT at this point
2. Assassin - Other than claiming town hasnt really provided much. Also... not sure why he claimed town so damn early. (Page 17) I have been suspicious of him based on how he is playing. I have voted and will keep my vote on him.
3. Minjae - Meta Analysis - Playing the same he did last game when he was Mafia. Uninvolved, not playing alot. scummy
4. Sin - Town sided - and knowledgable about the game. Would be willing to follow his lead on voting.
5. Mikey - Pass had him as town... I'm 60% sure he is correct, but not really sure. Can't really get a read on him.
6. Scribble - As others have said, he is more involved this game than usual. Doesn't really indicate anything.. I have been mafia with him before and he was lurking a lot. Might be SK??
7.Trigger Unhappy - I'm fucking adorable.
8. Blade - where to start... I am suspicious of blade, 2nd most to Assassin. It started when he immediately took his vote off Phil from a generic defense. Add that to the fact that he was providing incorrect information about NK (unintentionally?) ... Just getting a scummy vibe.
10. I'm a zambi - ... Vt most likely... Town probably wont miss him if he gets voted today. Don't understand why he seems to be following blade.
11. Cyber - Been too busy to comment much, havent been able to get a feel for him. As of now I would not vote for him.
12. Hosh - scummy- (always scummy though)
13. Pass- Most likely town sided.

[I'm a zambi]

10. I'm a zambi - ... Vt most likely...

Correct.

Town probably wont miss him if he gets voted today.

Thanks.

Don't understand why he seems to be following blade. [/QUOTE]
I haven't been following anyone, just myself.

[Passarelli]

13. Pass- Most likely town sided.

I'm number 9 asshat.

[I'm a zambi]

Don't understand why he seems to be following blade.

Mmm, I keep missing these tags.

[Nemesis]

I was going to say that using colours for anything but voting is against the rules, but then I remembered Mikey is colour blind and is probably confused as fuck. That's hilarious so carry on. Just try to distinguish any votes from the main text so I can find them.

[I'm a zambi]

I would keep my eyes on Assassin, Minjae, Blade and Hosh, unsure of SCRIBBLE and Trigger. I think everyone else is innocent.

- - - Updated - - -

I was going to say that using colours for anything but voting is against the rules, but then I remembered Mikey is colour blind and is probably confused as fuck. That's hilarious so carry on. Just try to distinguish any votes from the main text so I can find them.

LOL. Basically Mikey, Pass thinks that:

Phil and you are in the clear,
Sin and Cyber are likely town,
Trigger is in the middle,
Assassin and I are suspicious,
Hosh is more suspicious,
Blade even more,
and finally SCRIBBLE as most suspicious

if I'm reading the color codes correctly, which I think I am?

- - - Updated - - -

Forgot to list Minjae* tied with Hosh for suspicion, apparently

correct me if I'm wrong, that's what I took from your post!

- - - Updated - - -

Also, if I had to knock one of those out of my suspicions list, it'd probably be Blade or Hosh.

[Passarelli]

Stop making things easy for Mikey! Q.Q