Mafia Game: The Donner Party

[Nemesis]

Randomly killing as a vigilante is bad play, regardless of how you use the outcome, the action itself is bad and you should feel bad.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Randomly killing as a vigilante is bad play, regardless of how you use the outcome, the action itself is bad and you should feel bad.

neither kills were random. Killing hosh was obvious and outlined previously by me after the game. Killing scribble was a rookie reaction to what i thought was my untimely demise. His fake hammer duped me and had me thinking he was anti town after i thought i made it painfully obvious D1 what my role was.

[Nemesis]

Fine, random would be better, you just made terrible moves as a Vig. Thought you would have learned from last time.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Fine, random would be better, you just made terrible moves as a Vig. Thought you would have learned from last time.

I cant argue the fact that i didnt have a good game. It happens.
I do however, know how to play vig and even outlined several times in attempts to soft claim, that i did in fact know better. Explaining that vig should never kill N1 and yadda yadda.

I dont see an issue with my hosh kill though. It benefited town and was necessary given the circumstances and as you know, it could have just as easily been trigger if i hadnt changed my mind last minute.

[Nemesis]

But you're using hindsight to say you're right when you had no idea who you were killing at the start. Just because it worked out now it could have easily have gone very badly if the Mexicans showed up

[Assassin]

But you're using hindsight to say you're right when you had no idea who you were killing at the start. Just because it worked out now it could have easily have gone very badly if the Mexicans showed up

Damn mexicans.

[Sin]

Killing hosh didn't benefit town, Mikey.

[Sin]

I'd like to play this setup again.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Killing stupid people who imbalance odds, benfits everyone.

Gosh.

[Trigger Unhappy]

Then everyone should thank me for killing you.

- - - Updated - - -

I'd like to play this setup again.

Agreed-very enjoyable.