Mafia Game: The Donner Party

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

unvote
vote zambi

blade has more experience than zambi and would be more valuable to the game. considering mafia can talk during the day I would assume if blade and zambi were a team blade would be coaching zambi to stay the fuck away from him, especially first day.

if we get rid of zambi and he is town we have at least rid ourselves of someone who is unsure of themselves and the game. we can put more pressure on blade tomorrow if he is still suspected and if not then we saved ourselves a valuable townie.

Unless they thought both quick lynching phil would hammer... lawl but it didnt phil atill needs one vote. Look at the last sentence in there vote posts, is as if they anticipated the day to end.

[SCRIBBLE]

friendly reminder to town -- mafia has daytalk meaning they can communicate and adjust their strategy as they please.

- - - Updated - - -

Look at the last sentence in there vote posts, is as if they anticipated the day to end.

that caught my attention as well

[I'm a zambi]

Well I actually thought my vote was the last one needed, so that's kind of self-explanatory - nothing personal Phil, I just suspect you.

As far as Blade and me working together I really can't see where you see this. Blade's been inactive up until about page 13. I guess you could say that's strategy, but ... meh ... if you listen to everyone else I've apparently been following a 'vote train' - which I don't really see either, but I guess you guys do.

- - - Updated - - -

As Phil says, I'll gladly volunteer as tribute, but just know that you've got the wrong guy.

- - - Updated - - -

also, lolololololololol69posts @swagswagswagyolo

- - - Updated - - -

#* ...

- - - Updated - - -

I will say, Scribble, that after your contributions I'd have to move you from unsure to townie.

[Passarelli]

A few points:

• How was Phil's claim "decent" in your eyes? It was generic at best.

It was decent in that he didn't try overly hard, offered to sacrifice himself, and finally he didn't slip up. I didn't mean decent as good, simply okay.

• Cyber doesn't seem to be playing differently to you? He was on my radar for a bit, but I'm trying not to meta him. He's still on the fence though.

He seems to be playing as a VT. I haven't played with you vets in a closed setup, so it is hard to tell since he can't try gambits like he did last game. That said, I doubt he is a power role. He could be scum, but I'd say I'm 85% confident he is a VT.

• I agree with lynching Phillatio, as the safest bet. He didn't soft claim a Town PR, and his defense was week IMO.

Why wouldn't you want to continue a "fishing expedition"? In one of your previous posts you contradicted Hosh, I believe, about it being a GOOD thing that Day 1 extends up to even "50 pages". Now you're quick to jump to a lynch?

Enlighten me as to why you had such a sudden change of heart.

It wasn't really a change of heart. It is more that a wagon finally got high enough to force out a claim and the claim we got wasn't a power role. Scum is going to claim VT in this game because it is a closed set and they don't have enough people to sacrifice to eliminate any of the power roles. I don't mind the 50+ pages of discussion, but fishing and forcing out more people to claim will keep increasing the chances that scum will kill the power roles.

[SCRIBBLE]

I am going to do a count of who has alluded to being a VT.

[I'm a zambi]

So where do you stand as a whole Pass?

Call it scummy if you want, but I'd kind of like to know where everyone stands. Mikey and Scribble have convinced themselves that I'm working with Blade - what do the rest of you think?

- - - Updated - - -

Personally I'm still on the Phil bandwagon. Sorry Phil.

- - - Updated - - -

I am going to do a count of who has alluded to being a VT.

Well, wouldn't we all have, considering that's the only role to play it safe as?

[Sin]

UNVOTE

unvote
vote zambi

blade has more experience than zambi and would be more valuable to the game. considering mafia can talk during the day I would assume if blade and zambi were a team blade would be coaching zambi to stay the fuck away from him, especially first day.

if we get rid of zambi and he is town we have at least rid ourselves of someone who is unsure of themselves and the game. we can put more pressure on blade tomorrow if he is still suspected and if not then we saved ourselves a valuable townie.

I agree with the mindset of the possibility of Blade coaching Zambi, but I'm a little worried about your logic on then lynching Zambi instead of Blade, considering Blade's playstyle this game and further admittance of him playing scummy (See Below).

Playing scummy is fun though. If everyone played their part, then we would get nowhere and end up random lynching. Someone has to provide some change.

This doesn't help town at all, and as I don't like the way you're approaching this game, as well as the fact you deflected my questions earlier with more filler, I'm switching my vote.

that caught my attention as well

(See my inquiry above)

Well I actually thought my vote was the last one needed, so that's kind of self-explanatory - nothing personal Phil, I just suspect you.

As far as Blade and me working together I really can't see where you see this. Blade's been inactive up until about page 13. I guess you could say that's strategy, but ... meh ... if you listen to everyone else I've apparently been following a 'vote train' - which I don't really see either, but I guess you guys do.

- - - Updated - - -

As Phil says, I'll gladly volunteer as tribute, but just know that you've got the wrong guy.

- - - Updated - - -

also, lolololololololol69posts @swagswagswagyolo

- - - Updated - - -

#* ...

- - - Updated - - -

I will say, Scribble, that after your contributions I'd have to move you from unsure to townie.

- Piggybacking someone else's defense (an already generic defense).
- For someone who only pages ago went back through the thread and did votecount per request, it's weird that you wouldn't do the same before possibly hammering someone? Itchy trigger finger?
- The only thing scribble really added to the discussion were his detailed views on Cyber (which I agree with), so not sure WHY his "contributions" gave you a townread on him.

Oh and...
VOTE BLADE

[I'm a zambi]

I agree with the mindset of the possibility of Blade coaching Zambi

But really, no such thing has happened. With Blade or anyone else.

- Piggybacking someone else's defense (an already generic defense).

What? Volunteering as 'tribute'?

- For someone who only pages ago went back through the thread and did votecount per request, it's weird that you wouldn't do the same before possibly hammering someone? Itchy trigger finger?

Athlete's Finger. SO itchy. Honestly I just want to see the outcome for today, even if it is me who ends up getting lynched.

- The only thing scribble really added to the discussion were his detailed views on Cyber (which I agree with), so not sure WHY his "contributions" gave you a townread on him.

I don't actually know really. I guess just the nature of his post. It seemed genuine - I don't think he's trying to hide anything.

I think I'll stick with Phil this time.

[Trigger Unhappy]

Sigh, we have 2 people claiming vt. Both of which I'm still suspicious of. Nambi is all over the place with his voting. If we were going the safe route of lynching one of then I would vote Nambi. Phil will be more useful to town in terms of analysis.

- - - Updated - - -

I do however think we should wait and talk it out more. I also need to take time a read this over again

[Sin]

But really, no such thing has happened. With Blade or anyone else.


What? Volunteering as 'tribute'?


Athlete's Finger. SO itchy. Honestly I just want to see the outcome for today, even if it is me who ends up getting lynched.



I don't actually know really. I guess just the nature of his post. It seemed genuine - I don't think he's trying to hide anything.

I think I'll stick with Phil this time.

Why are you in such a rush to end Day 1 in your first game?

Also... TBH After the post Blade made joking about "playing scummy", my vote will not be changing today. If you don't want to aid town, then you're either anti-town or scum. Simple.