Mafia Game: The Donner Party

[Sin]

So I'll take that as a claim to Tasty Vanilla.

Unvote

Works for me for the time being.

For someone who's condemned people on this site for "believing claims so easily", this strikes me as odd. Fishing for the Vig, Blade?

Yeah, I'm not really sure how to take that statement either. Phil's still on my suspect list.

- - - Updated - - -

as far as I'm concerned, my sights are set on Phil, Trigger, Cyber (because of tha uuugh comment) and Assassin most of all

- - - Updated - - -

also, quick addition, wouldn't I be more silent if I were mafia? (last sentence of Phil's statement)

Is anyone reading to you as town, in particular? And inactivity does not equate to scum, as shown in the last Role Madness game with Nemesis.

So just for the record, Phil still smells. He made a decent claim as a VT, however.

That said, unless we want to further increase Scum's chance to hit power roles, we should likely proceed with the lynch unless someone else has decent reads so far.

Right now I feel that Assassin and to a lesser extent Scribble could be SK or mafia. I doubt Scribble is Mafia because he hasn't really talked day 1 like he did last game, just shown up to vote which is similar to what he did previously.

Blade is 98% right about Mikey (your play style does change ever so slightly when you are scum--at least in the one game I played with you), however he could be SK since he doesn't have to worry about anything else.

Zambi is new and I kinda doubt that if he were scum his partner would let him parade around like this. Zambi, so you are aware--there is a huge gulf between actually being good (which I still am not) and being competent. It isn't hard understanding the rules, but it takes a while to be able to get accurate reads on people (which is why Mikey won his last game as Scum. I couldn't pick up the small tells he gave. Now that I've played a few more games with him, I feel more confident I could spot him)

Cyber is Cyber. I haven't gotten a great read off of him but I doubt he is Mafia. Most likely town though SK is possible. And don't knock my popcorn! I made it the old fashioned way with oil and kernels in a pot covered with foil! Turned out pretty well. Mexican food is decent once in a while, but you mexicans eat it waaaay too often. I'll stick with my dago cuisine. Going to make stuffed shells tonight. And no, I won't stuff any of your shells, I'm talking about pasta.

Blade decided to join the party. He hasn't done anything very scummy as of yet.

That is about what I have thus far.

A few points:

• How was Phil's claim "decent" in your eyes? It was generic at best.

• Cyber doesn't seem to be playing differently to you? He was on my radar for a bit, but I'm trying not to meta him. He's still on the fence though.

• I agree with lynching Phillatio, as the safest bet. He didn't soft claim a Town PR, and his defense was week IMO.

I'm waiting from word from Blade/Mikey/Cyber/Sin if they want to continue the fishing expedition or hold off. I'd have put Scribbles in there, but the most we'd get from him is an unvote.

Why wouldn't you want to continue a "fishing expedition"? In one of your previous posts you contradicted Hosh, I believe, about it being a GOOD thing that Day 1 extends up to even "50 pages". Now you're quick to jump to a lynch?

Enlighten me as to why you had such a sudden change of heart.

[I'm a zambi]

Is anyone reading to you as town, in particular? And inactivity does not equate to scum, as shown in the last Role Madness game with Nemesis.

I believe Pass and Mikey are town. Pretty sure you are too.
Unsure of: Scribble, Blade, Cyber, Minjae, Trigger, Hosh
Suspect: Phil, Assassin

For Cyber the only thing that triggers suspicion for me is that one 'uugh' confirmation at the beginning of the game, but that could be for any number of reasons.

Well the only reason I truly believe Assassin is mafia is the odd 'Vote Phil' out of nowhere, but I guess the same could be said for any vote that happened at the beginning of the game.

Unvote Assassin
Vote Phil
Here goes nothin'.

[Passarelli]

A few points:

• How was Phil's claim "decent" in your eyes? It was generic at best.

It was decent in that he didn't try overly hard, offered to sacrifice himself, and finally he didn't slip up. I didn't mean decent as good, simply okay.

• Cyber doesn't seem to be playing differently to you? He was on my radar for a bit, but I'm trying not to meta him. He's still on the fence though.

He seems to be playing as a VT. I haven't played with you vets in a closed setup, so it is hard to tell since he can't try gambits like he did last game. That said, I doubt he is a power role. He could be scum, but I'd say I'm 85% confident he is a VT.

• I agree with lynching Phillatio, as the safest bet. He didn't soft claim a Town PR, and his defense was week IMO.

Why wouldn't you want to continue a "fishing expedition"? In one of your previous posts you contradicted Hosh, I believe, about it being a GOOD thing that Day 1 extends up to even "50 pages". Now you're quick to jump to a lynch?

Enlighten me as to why you had such a sudden change of heart.

It wasn't really a change of heart. It is more that a wagon finally got high enough to force out a claim and the claim we got wasn't a power role. Scum is going to claim VT in this game because it is a closed set and they don't have enough people to sacrifice to eliminate any of the power roles. I don't mind the 50+ pages of discussion, but fishing and forcing out more people to claim will keep increasing the chances that scum will kill the power roles.