Mafia Game: The Donner Party

[BladeTwinSwords]

Zambi, I'm pretty sure you're not mafia but someone has to take the fall.

- - - Updated - - -

You are the most suspicious of anyone so you will probably end up being the target.

[I'm a zambi]

Since I'm correct in that assumption, doesn't what I just posted negate suspicion on Blade?

- - - Updated - - -

Zambi, I'm pretty sure you're not mafia but someone has to take the fall.

Indeed.

You are the most suspicious of anyone so you will probably end up being the target.

I have no doubt.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Since I'm correct in that assumption, doesn't what I just posted negate suspicion on Blade?

Not even remotely. I will probably be investigated, come back Not Cannibal and then everything about me is thrown out the window and we waste a day for nothing.

[I'm a zambi]

Not even remotely. I will probably be investigated, come back Not Cannibal and then everything about me is thrown out the window and we waste a day for nothing.

lol - lynching me would be a waste of a day as well, honestly - but I guess you guys need your tributee

[BladeTwinSwords]

lol - lynching me would be a waste of a day as well, honestly - but I guess you guys need your tributee

I'm more worried about all the power roles using their abilities on one person.

[Sin]

1. Phillatio - Had condemning interactions early-game. Lots of filler. Got defensive as soon as someone made a serious mention of him being scum. Has a town "tone" when posting, probably because he's asian. Possible SK/Most likely Town. Sheep.

2. Assassin - Has had condemning interactions throughout the game. Quick voted without explanation after "RVS" was over. Possibly being coached, poorly. Seems as though he's given up. Comes off as depressed. Possible Mafia Affiliation. Sheep.

3. Minjae - No condemning interactions, though his lack of original thought and input shines through his font. Not confident in expressing his opinions about other. Probably has mommy issues. Town read. Sheep.

4. Sin - Fucking amazing. CONFIRMED TOWN.

5. Mikey - Has had condemning interactions throughout the game. Quick voted Blade without definitive reason; rookie mistake. Has confused rules/abbreviations from different sites multiple times, no evidence of scum tactics just Mikey being Mikey. May have slipped in various posts. Lots of filler. Jumped on Zambi wagon trying to divert attention towards Blade, when attention was already on Blade. Scum tone. Possible SK.

6. Scribble - Condemning interactions early-game. Lots of filler. Gameplay changed drastically from early to mid-game Day 1. Possible Mafia Affiliation.

7. Trigger Unhappy - No condemning interactions. Some "fake" votes. Town tone.

8. Blade - I've said all I need to say about him. Complete disregard for towns mission of fishing out scum by painting a target on himself. IF Town-Aligned, Mafia will keep him in play. He is the "Nemesis" of this game. This guy is fucking scum. Most likely to win the Faggiest SK/Town Ever Award.

9. Pass - No condemning interactions. Brought up valid points when pressed for answers. Asks the right questions. Town tone.

10. I'm a zambi - Not Confirmed Town. Too many condemning interactions. Early-game joking switched to panicked defenses across various pages. For a new player his gameplay has focused and he is beginning to think for himself in the latter stages of Day 1, which brings up the concern of being coached. Town tone, but would vote him if necessary just to not lynch a power role. The Artist formerly known as Sheep.


11. Cyber - No condemning interactions. Not trying to meta him. Comes off as coaching, someone. Fishiest player of the game besides Blade. Voted Trigger Early, and in same post stated he wanted to Vote Scribble. Possible Headcoach slip? Using unoriginal excuse, and overly concerned with people suspecting him of lurking. Comes off as scum playing town. Possible Mafia Affiliation.

12. Hosh - No condemning posts. Stuck to his word on voting. Asked some good questions. Came up with original thoughts, proving useful. In general comes off as Town, but possible scum evasion and generic inactivity tactics. Possibly being coached.

- - - Updated - - -

Also, just to remind everyone, veterans included:

Day 1(D1) lynches are usually town. If you know that you're town you should want to stay alive and if you're concerned about your image maybe you should play better the following day. We're not going to auto lynch you just because you were on this wagon, that would be stupid and lazy.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

1. Phillatio - Had condemning interactions early-game. Lots of filler. Got defensive as soon as someone made a serious mention of him being scum. Has a town "tone" when posting, probably because he's asian. Possible SK/Most likely Town. Sheep.

2. Assassin - Has had condemning interactions throughout the game. Quick voted without explanation after "RVS" was over. Possibly being coached, poorly. Seems as though he's given up. Comes off as depressed. Possible Mafia Affiliation. Sheep.

3. Minjae - No condemning interactions, though his lack of original thought and input shines through his font. Not confident in expressing his opinions about other. Probably has mommy issues. Town read. Sheep.

4. Sin - Fucking amazing. CONFIRMED TOWN.

5. Mikey - Has had condemning interactions throughout the game. Quick voted Blade without definitive reason; rookie mistake. Has confused rules/abbreviations from different sites multiple times, no evidence of scum tactics just Mikey being Mikey. May have slipped in various posts. Lots of filler. Jumped on Zambi wagon trying to divert attention towards Blade, when attention was already on Blade. Scum tone. Possible SK.

6. Scribble - Condemning interactions early-game. Lots of filler. Gameplay changed drastically from early to mid-game Day 1. Possible Mafia Affiliation.

7. Trigger Unhappy - No condemning interactions. Some "fake" votes. Town tone.

8. Blade - I've said all I need to say about him. Complete disregard for towns mission of fishing out scum by painting a target on himself. IF Town-Aligned, Mafia will keep him in play. He is the "Nemesis" of this game. This guy is fucking scum. Most likely to win the Faggiest SK/Town Ever Award.

9. Pass - No condemning interactions. Brought up valid points when pressed for answers. Asks the right questions. Town tone.

10. I'm a zambi - Not Confirmed Town. Too many condemning interactions. Early-game joking switched to panicked defenses across various pages. For a new player his gameplay has focused and he is beginning to think for himself in the latter stages of Day 1, which brings up the concern of being coached. Town tone, but would vote him if necessary just to not lynch a power role. The Artist formerly known as Sheep.


11. Cyber - No condemning interactions. Not trying to meta him. Comes off as coaching, someone. Fishiest player of the game besides Blade. Voted Trigger Early, and in same post stated he wanted to Vote Scribble. Possible Headcoach slip? Using unoriginal excuse, and overly concerned with people suspecting him of lurking. Comes off as scum playing town. Possible Mafia Affiliation.

12. Hosh - No condemning posts. Stuck to his word on voting. Asked some good questions. Came up with original thoughts, proving useful. In general comes off as Town, but possible scum evasion and generic inactivity tactics. Possibly being coached.

- - - Updated - - -

Also, just to remind everyone, veterans included:

Day 1(D1) lynches are usually town. If you know that you're town you should want to stay alive and if you're concerned about your image maybe you should play better the following day. We're not going to auto lynch you just because you were on this wagon, that would be stupid and lazy.

It was not a simple quick lynch on blade, it was a lynch with nothing added to hunt reactions. Those reactions are part of the reason we are at our current empasse. You know better then most here. Why misinform people about the true itent behind some of my actions?

- - - Updated - - -

Also, I have already explained reasonings behind blade and zambi. Go back and re read. What filler?

I mean, I was only sorta of joking when I said you were sk. But I am not even sure anymore. To think you soft claimed and now this.

[BladeTwinSwords]

I have done my job well.

- - - Updated - - -

By that I mean being Nemesis. You gotta have that one asshole player.

[Sin]

Mikey, I'm going to ISO a few of your posts here for further review. See below:

Can we get a vote count plea. Kthx
Also, people.... Note reactions to votes. How people react to being voted.
Look at those who appear to be trying hard when tryhards are not necessary.

- - - Updated - - -

My current read? We have a bunch of tasty townies playing patty cake on a forum thread.

Great pro-tip above, althought the WAY that you chose to go about it is indicative of lazy reaction testing. This isn't EpicMafia, where you can track votes in the chat and respond IMMEDIATELY to them. In a forum setup you need more, a town play would ALWAYS include backing/reasoning for a vote, Mikey. What I did was a great reaction test, by the way you reacted.

The second part of this quote is filler and possible projection of your cannibalistic ways.

Why are you getting defensive over my post?

Yeah Mikey, why are you getting defensive over my post?

as i always like to never say...
I fos everyone so therefore i am at least 100% correct that at least one of them is maf.

Why say it then? Lazy at best, anti-town at worst.

You dont tell me what to do serial killer. Im sexy and I know it.

Filler and projection?

Sigh.

This game is going to be tough.
If killer and maf can joint win, we absoutly have to kill one by end of day tmrw. Otherwise pray one dies at night.

Im not personally getting a scum read off phil but I will have to go over all the posts when I get home from work.

This game IS tough. Why would you even think that they could joint-win? Trying to lead people into meaningless banter like you did with the NK/NK debacle last night?

You didn't even go over all of the posts when you got home, and if you didn't you didn't update us with your thoughts. Scum trying to look town? Possibly.

Unless they thought both quick lynching phil would hammer... lawl but it didnt phil atill needs one vote. Look at the last sentence in there vote posts, is as if they anticipated the day to end.

Good work here. Would read again.

I am still suspicous of blade. Will be back after I get home from work in about 2 hours.

I dont think we should stall this anymore, we have a ml and we should stick with who we plan to lynch. Further pushing will result in more role claims and the more vts the enemy knows the larger percentage the enemy will hit a valuable asset too town.

At first you cast your suspicion. You then go on to state you will be gone for 2 hours, but you want to get to a mislynch before you even disappear? All of this knowing full well town would possibly be out (4) votes going into Day 2. To quote you "are you mad?" - Mikey 2014

Keep in mine the night phase. There is a possibility 4 townies die tonight, best case scenario only 2. We wont know if they were townies either.

See ^ for my response.

Sorry bad guys, I lied. I will not be hammering zambi.

Filler. Also, you all of a sudden no longer want to rush a mislynch on a "claimed" townie? What's with the switcheroo?

vote zambi

Now blade. Dont be a debby and ruin thia for everyone. The balls in your court now.

- - - Updated - - -

I.e. my last fos now has no votes and has to choose between being hammer or waiting for town to post there fos reports.

Additionally, im 90% certain no one will sneak hammer. Even though I think we should commit to lynching zambi.

This logic is weird. Blade had already unvoted, Zambi. Why does it matter to TOWN, if YOU put Zambi back to L-1? Anyone could have done it. Blade is smart enough not to hammer anyway, and smart enough to jump off of a wagon on a potential townie. You putting Zambie back to L-1 means shit.

That being said, kids. THAT is how you reaction test in a forum game format.

- - - Updated - - -

I'm more worried about all the power roles using their abilities on one person.

Don't worry about what the PR's choose to do, and stop trying to impact their decisions you cretin fuck.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Mikey, I'm going to ISO a few of your posts here for further review. See below:



Great pro-tip above, althought the WAY that you chose to go about it is indicative of lazy reaction testing. This isn't EpicMafia, where you can track votes in the chat and respond IMMEDIATELY to them. In a forum setup you need more, a town play would ALWAYS include backing/reasoning for a vote, Mikey. What I did was a great reaction test, by the way you reacted.

The second part of this quote is filler and possible projection of your cannibalistic ways.



Yeah Mikey, why are you getting defensive over my post?



Why say it then? Lazy at best, anti-town at worst.



Filler and projection?



This game IS tough. Why would you even think that they could joint-win? Trying to lead people into meaningless banter like you did with the NK/NK debacle last night?

You didn't even go over all of the posts when you got home, and if you didn't you didn't update us with your thoughts. Scum trying to look town? Possibly.




Good work here. Would read again.



At first you cast your suspicion. You then go on to state you will be gone for 2 hours, but you want to get to a mislynch before you even disappear? All of this knowing full well town would possibly be out (4) votes going into Day 2. To quote you "are you mad?" - Mikey 2014



See ^ for my response.



Filler. Also, you all of a sudden no longer want to rush a mislynch on a "claimed" townie? What's with the switcheroo?



This logic is weird. Blade had already unvoted, Zambi. Why does it matter to TOWN, if YOU put Zambi back to L-1? Anyone could have done it. Blade is smart enough not to hammer anyway, and smart enough to jump off of a wagon on a potential townie. You putting Zambie back to L-1 means shit.

That being said, kids. THAT is how you reaction test in a forum game format.

- - - Updated - - -



Don't worry about what the PR's choose to do, and stop trying to impact their decisions you cretin fuck.

hardly reaction testing as you misinterpreted more than half of what im saying in those posts. Im not defensive, simply clearing up some of your hystarical ideas forming from posts I have made.

Trigger deduced my reasoning with the zambie and blade voting part, did you miss it?

Additionally, by not stalling I implied that we should stick with who we want to ml and stop derailing votes and picking new votes. That leads to mass defense claims which hurt town. I personally beilive prolonging day phases as long as we typically do, is a double edged sword and people should be aware of that.

- - - Updated - - -

Also, by doing what I did I managed to stall a potential hammer so everyone had a chance to post there fos lists. Town has control over votes atm, its a win.