Mafia Game: Monster Mash (Hosted by Sin and What)

[hoshiro-]

Ohhh Phil <3

[Passarelli]

I'm voting you because you fucking claimed, and the fact that you claimed "town pr" when the masons are already out pretty much makes you a werewolf day 2.

I still think Minjae is scummy, but the fact that you claimed without even trying to talk town down is scummy, especially given what you claimed. I think you are just trying to talk town down or at least try to fish out a power role before getting lynched. Since you already claimed that much, why not claim your role and see if you get CCed?

[phil.™]

No, I claimed because I was what, L-2? This day prolonged way too far where anyone would have jumped on a wagon. I claimed because some people need to learn to actually be patient and scum hunt versus going for policy lynch.

Your continuance to vote me after, you are either mafia or werewolf. Town would not vote another town. Even after a claim, a town pr claim at that.
I'm worthless now, but this still gives town a chance to win.

[Passarelli]

Or at least explain why going ahead and hard claiming would be a bad idea, considering you already claimed one of the two power roles.

[phil.™]

I just re-read. Hahaha, your last sentence. Hahahahahahha. You want me to hard claim as town pr.
Hahahahahahah. And give out more information than I already, or we already gave out.

[Passarelli]

It seems to me that you are just trying to make both power roles out themselves in order to counter you. I really want to know why you are refusing to even allow the chance of being counter claimed. If you can at least give a decent reason, I'll back off but just claiming "town pr" seems pretty scummy when there are only two power roles left, and neither has immunity to conversion.

- - - Updated - - -

You already gave out to much information. I don't see what the harm of at least making you a confirmed townie would be instead of an ambiguous, "zomg, I'm a town pr. Don't lynch me unless both town PRs out themselves to counter me!"

[phil.™]

Because nobody will cc, and now that's 3 of 4 known pr. Why are you trying out town so hard?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Because nobody will cc, and now that's 3 of 4 known pr. Why are you trying out town so hard?

no one will cc it because the last 2 pr's dont know who the other ones are. So of course it is conveient to claim pr, knowing no one can cc you. it isnt a matter of whether or not they WANT to cc you.. they simply cant.

[Passarelli]

Because knowing your role doesn't matter. You painted a sign on your back sayin "Target me!"

Maybe I don't believe you because the odds of the wagons hitting 2 town power roles are pretty outrageously high, as well as your refusal to give an additional piece of information which would actually allow for town to either confirm you as town OR lynch you as scum.

That said, Mikey, now that this happened, what do you think we should do? Do you think it'd at least be worth people claiming their roles so we increase the odds today to 25% to hit a WW, 50% to hit scum?

- - - Updated - - -

no one will cc it because the last 2 pr's dont know who the other ones are. So of course it is conveient to claim pr, knowing no one can cc you. it isnt a matter of whether or not they WANT to cc you.. they simply cant.

This.

Also, I don't think it is a great idea to claim roles now, but we are fast approaching the point where it'd actually be better for us to claim.

[phil.™]

Pass, what would like me to say?
Oh we have two confirmed masons that nobody cc. I'm L-2 and I'm just a townie?!?
My original point was to prove to hosh that policy lynch, "not so responsive players" is not always scummy.

We already lost. So go ahead, lynch me. I know for a fact 2/4 mafia/werewolf voted for me.

So if I do get lynched, everyone look at those who voted for me.