I snipped some stuff. Sorry if I took some things out of context. I will say that I haven't been following this debate so I may not have all of the information necessary to leave a comment here but I think most of what is said does not require context.
I think it may be time for rule re-defining, since it seems that there are some (by some I mean A LOT OF) gray areas. A clear black and white ruling for specific instances would greatly help when it comes to moderating the servers, especially in the case of an abusing admin. I think what you mention is largely an issue of misunderstanding the rules rather than enforcing 'corrupted versions'.
True. All of this is true.
Fuck'em.