Blade and Nem's IBIS Themed Mafia Game (Insanity Game #1)

[Passarelli]

So town has 5 people. 2 of which are masons and one is a bomb. Scribble, is your partner BM or stars?

This means someone is lying or scum will be much easier to find. Right now I'm leaning towards someone lying, but a solid investigation should clear up most of this.

This also means a cop will be able to clear two towns with 1 investigation, or find both mafia at once. Not bad.

Scribble, is that the only power you have, or are you as useless as Cyber now?

unvote

[StarsMine]

So town has 5 people. 2 of which are masons and one is a bomb. Scribble, is your partner BM or stars?

This means someone is lying or scum will be much easier to find. Right now I'm leaning towards someone lying, but a solid investigation should clear up most of this.

This also means a cop will be able to clear two towns with 1 investigation, or find both mafia at once. Not bad.

Scribble, is that the only power you have, or are you as useless as Cyber now?

unvote

Scribble can still use all his abilities (night talk). Hard claiming does not inherently make you useless, he can still be targeted as well.

[Passarelli]

Stars, you know that a townie that can't be killed is useful, right?

What did you want him to do? Claim a major power role to try to force a mafia kill? Except then that role might CC and we'd Lynch Cyber and be down an extra person and a major power role would be exposed. As it is now, we'll still be OK if 2 people die at night and we mislynch.

If someone can clear Cyber, we'd have a cleared townie that will not die.

I'd rather not risk voting him which would stop a JoaT or a Vig to not be able to use their shots.

At this point though, I think our best move would be to Lynch off one of the unclaimed people and the investigative role should fact check Scribble. This will give us 1-2 confirmed townies for tomorrow or serve mafia on a platter. If Cyber is lying, that means he is either Mafia or survivor. If he is mafia, that means his partner and 3rd party is among the unknowns. If he is survivor, both mafia are among the unknowns. If both he and scrib are truthful, then that means 3/5 unclaimed players are scum. Playing it out this way means we would have a worst case scenario of a 2/5 chance of hitting scum today and a 2/4 chance tomorrow. If there is a vig shot tonight, we'd have worst case a 33% chance of hitting mafia, 66% chance at scum. Not the best odds, but when you look at the odds of as town in winning 5v2v1, it's promising.

I think that math is right, I'm not home to put shit into notepad.

[Assassin]

Unvote
Though I still don't think scribble is off my watch list.

[Blackmage]

Spending the night thinking about things, finding we may have a mason may make things tricky. Remember the starting flavour. "Also this shall be a day start because you fuckwits need to learn not to rely so much on your night powers." While this setup is "1. It is NOT very balanced as it can include ANYTHING.", do we think we'd be given a cop, much less a sane cop if we truly have 2 masons? Added with the quote from the scum page on mason "Some moderators consider two Masons to be a roughly equivalent substitute for a Cop.", we may be hard pressed to clear anyone at night.

Note, I won't be hammering till we at least discuss this, even if it's just to say STFU blackmage.

- - - Updated - - -

Blackmage - Cyber, unvote, pass, unvote, cyber, unvote
Pass - Ass, unvote, scrib, unvote
Ass - Pass, Unvote, Stars, unvote, Scribble, unvote, scrib, unvote
Scrib - Cyber
Rosie - Stars, unvote, cyber
Trig - Rosie, unvote
Stars - Cyber
Cyber - BM

Supposing no vote changers:

Assassin 0
Blackmage 1 (L-4)
Pass 0
Rosie 0
Scrib 0
Stars 0
Trig 0
Cyber 3 (L-2)

[Rosie]

If we do have 2 Masons, a bomb, I know that I am pretty damn helpful, and another role, it seems like a cop may almost over balance the game to town side. Unless Mafia has like a bulletproof godfather with a janitor or something. Or if the 3rd party is a SK.

- - - Updated - - -

Assuming its 5v2v1

Could it be possibly 4v2v2 with the masons being 3rd party? Honest question btw, wont know if I don't ask.

[Assassin]

Well my role is pretty damn powerful as well so...I'm going to go ahead and guess no on the town side cop.

[Passarelli]

Rosie, 4v2v2 with the masons actually being mafia is more likely then them being 3rd party.

You guys need to keep in mind that mafia likely also has strong power roles in this.

That said, Trig, I think I trust you the most in this game thus far. What did you want to do?

[Trigger Unhappy]

Here is what we have established so far... No double voter... or at least.. none of the people that actually voted for cyber were double voters.

it looks like Scrib and Stars are partners it looks like.. though Stars was really sure that BM wasnt a lyncher... which i tend to agree.

There is some doubt as to whether a town cop is present in the game. My gut feeling from the flavor is that there is not one. So we can't really verify Scrib or Cyber's claim. my thinking is that BM, and Pass are town. Assassin is a little all over the place, but I think thats just his play style..

I'm leaning Stars as scum partly because of his push on cyber. If cyber is really bomb, it is in towns interest to keep him alive. especially in a 4v2v2 scenario.
I have what i think should be done tonight by various power roles.. the last time we had an insanity game there was a bus driver (me) and so i don't want to publish what i think various roles should do.

- - - Updated - - -

also just fyi guys, just bought a house this week. Moving today and tomorrow so will be out of touch until around 5 ish.

[StarsMine]

It would be foolish to put myself out there like this if I was scum. If cyber is bomb, we pretty much already lost, and if I was mafia pushing this hard is suicidal.