I'm trying to see if there could be a clear downside to mass claiming flavor, and can not really see one, which appears to be a fatal flaw in this setup. Unless Scribble went off script and has several obscure characters in lieu of more obvious ones its kind of a done deal. 7 Dwarves + Snow White will certainly be town, and that's 8 right there, we have 11 people total, so in essence those extra 3 are likely to all be scum, either 3 mafia or 2 mafia and a third party.