Sounds a lot more like you are a Lyncher, and Scrib is your Lynchee. You will not say how you know Scrib is mafia, just that he is.

Zambi, my guess would be that it was 3v2v1v1. Pass lie detected a Miller, or a Unknown Mafia Traitor. That could also explain the lack of a night kill. If Scum targeted their traitor the Mod may disallow the kill. Although I am not sure that a Miller would bypass your lie detector. I do agree with What in the fact that my money is on there being a Mafia team though. I just think he is on it.