I have gamefly its been great I bought many games dirt cheap there. You have to know how to get the games you want though when they release or it will take forever to get that particular game if its in high demand. Only problem I have now is i tend to use them less and less since I'm primarily on PC now. I bought Fear 2 for 7 bucks last month and I could have traded back to them for 16. Never received a bad used game from them