ok , i just saw this thread. THIS IS A VERY DETAILED AND IMPORTANT REPORT FOR THE MODERATORS/UPPER/CLAN when making their judgement , evreyone else can SKIP TO CONCLUSION FOR MY OPINION.
i'm trying to be objective here but here are the facts.
1- i checked the player scores and then i saw LA in spec, apparently he was there for a few mins, and some "claimed" that he was already playing before moving to spec.
2- he disconnected, then not even a split second later he re-joined AND STARTED PLAYING.
3- he was repeatedly asked by whiskey as to "why did u disconnect LA?" over, and over again, i'm not sure but i think i typed it out in chat as well. and HE DIDNT REPLY, AT ALL.
4- whiskey SLAYED him once, not kicked, not banned, SLAYED him "under the illusion that he disconnected intentionally for bypassing levels and not clearing that issue up" . And i distinctively remember a player mentioning that LA has done that as well just the night before.
5- not even a SPLIT second after whiskey slayed him, LA started crying out on the mic ask he was slayed.
6- whiskey was probably afk or didnt hear him , so i answered LA stating that "u were thought to bypass levels". and everything went downhill since, and LA wouldnt let the issue go, at the expense of the game , where other regulars started to get annoyed at the fact that he was dragging this on and on and on for 2 maps , until whiskey finally gave him a 5 minute break ON THE NEXT MAP so he can cool down and i remmeber him saying "we will hug it out in a few, just chill plz".
7- even then, LA kept argueing through the chat... and thats when i barged into the conversation putting an end to it .
now here are my 2 cents :
yes, whiskey was in the wrong to slay him because apparently the guy did not bypass leveling. and technically, one can call it admin abuse.
HOWEVER: whiskey did NOT ban or kick the guy, he simply slayed him once. For a guy that was in spec for a while and NOT playing, a couple levels away is not the end of the world... you could have recovered these 2 levels if you were actually PLAYING? it's like you got slayed for throwing a bad nade... you werent banned man... but a wrongful slay is still a wrongful admin command so still read this :
- La, you probably got disconnected because "YOU WERE AFK FOR 2 LONG" by the server and not bypassing levels, but, u were hogging up a reserved slot for a while, and they are hard to get into. next time please just leave the server and come back after a while.
- LA why did you not clear the whole issue up when the admins asked you? its not like whiskey just took the admin hammer and slammed it on u without first getting your side of the story... you CHOSE not to answer, the admin has every right to think that you probably did commit the alleged accusation and didnt wanna argue, specially if u were asked both verbally and in text to answer whiskey's question, by TWO admins.
- la, i find it a "coincidence" that, not only did u conveniently came back as soon as u got disconnected (which means u were on the computer but not playing) thus hogging a slot, but also that you immediately started playing (or else whiskey would obviously not be able to slay a spectator ) and ALSO you did not speak a single word until you were slayed... please try to understand that your actions show that you only care about urself and that u are a bit fishy.
- considering that in order to be 100% sure that a person leveled up with disconnect can only be proven with a demo, whiskey would have had to quit the server, get the source Tv and confirm then, by which time the map would have probably ended without the player being properly assessed (if he actually DID bypass, ... and ur mysterious silence tends to point on out that u dnt give a fuck about the admin talkign to u and it means that ur character is consistent with ppl that wouldnt mind bypassing levels. so whiskey had to take action on the spot and review the source tv later, like in this thread.
- its just a slay man... get it over with it . you could have went on steam and discussed the issue like grown men with whiskey and explain the issue. i am sure he would have been happy to apologize because most of us admins actually HATE handing in punishments because of the fiasco that comes with them... i do.
- instead of solving the confusion, you decided to accuse whiskey of admin abusing on the spot, and being ego centric smthn(forgot what u said), admin power hungry and that he is stupid ( btw, when u tell someone that he is unintelligent in the middle of an arguement, YES it is equivalent to stupid), instead of talking calmly about the issue. yes, sure he slayed u for a wrongfully alleged reason, but not because he was power hungry, but because it was technically ur fault for being too shady and not clearing up ur name in the first place. any admin would put on earplugs after u disrespect them like that .
-and technically whiskey did too, and so did other players. i heard and saw many players complain that you were disrupting the server for argueing with the admin in game, and you were muted for FIVE MINUTES for disrupting the server, not because of the initial issue, so please dont tie them both to the same cause. the mute was a 100 % reasonable, because the admin wanted u to relax so he can discuss the issue with u calmly and not with name calling. (read the server rules on the forums: YOU DONT ARGUE WITH AN ADMIN IN THE SERVER BECAUSE IT DISRUPTS THE GAME, TAKE IT TO STEAM FIRST THEN A THREAD. and this all could have been bypassed in the first place...)
- u kept argueing in game regardless... and i asked u politely to stop the discussion because it was very annoying. and finally u did, left and posted this thread. (im almost positive u didnt even talk to whiskey on steam first)...
SO CONCLUSION: yes, whiskey technically slayed him for no reason, but i don't think he deserves the title of admin abuse because if you see the above report, you will understand that whiskey did not just slay him for no reason, he took into account all the shit that happened and ASSESSED that he should be slayn (not even kicked or banned, just slayed to be taught a lesson) and had almost every right to do what he did, and i dnt want to stick my head out there bcos i really dont give a fuck, but i would have done the same thing with the slay and the mute. (+ - a few intermediary steps for fun) ... everyone makes mistakes, this was a mistake that sprouted from a communication confusion that started with LA not helping the admin out understanding the facts.
LA, i wasnt trying to defend whiskey, i honestly just met the guy, and im not trying to accuse u neither. im stating the facts that are recorded, and i have nthn against u , it was all a confusion... shit happens. now get ur ass in game so i can knife it cyber style!:P u 2 whiskey, just hug it out and move along...
Originally Posted by ZERO
Register To Reply
