Punish people like you witnessed it, providing the complaint comes from a somewhat reliable source, and let the problem player make the thread. Don't make the person having their game ruined make the thread about another player.
Lots of problems come from punishing people on word, that is why it is rare you see admins doing so, even from word of regs. There is more to lose for the admin than the player that may or may not be doing something wrong.
Make all your last demands for I will forsake you and I'll meet your eyes for the very first time, for the very last.
maynard <ibis>: they are awkward and last 2 damn long. I prefer thinner smaller ones