Mafia Game: The Donner Party

[minjae]

My vote is still for zambi. Even though he's new, he's playing aggressive in the way that he's posting a whole lot, but not putting in much important info.
Then again, neither am I. But like other games, I don't have nearly enough experience as you guys do, nor can I read people well.

My gut just tells me he's mafia, for now, until we got more useful info.

As of right now though, my suspicions are on *BLANK* cause I have no fucking idea yet, BUT I do think most of everyone is town, for now.
Regardless as of this moment, I'm going with Zambi.
If everyone thinks a no lynch is better than POSSIBLY lynching a power role, I'm up for it. But waiting on everyone's response in trying to figure out who's who would be better.
Taking time and narrowing it down is better than hurrying with the lynch.

[SCRIBBLE]

Zambi is possibly making an attempt to get me to take my focus off him by moving me from unsure to town.

I am comfortable with voting blade, zambi, or hosh.

I read through everything again (zambi and phil are only ones to claim vt so far) and hosh is playing so much differently than the last games. It is strange behavior for someone so new, could be some coaching there.

[I'm a zambi]

Zambi is possibly making an attempt to get me to take my focus off him by moving me from unsure to town.

Nope. Just calling it as I see it.

- - - Updated - - -

If you and/or Mikey are mafia, you've done a pretty good job of shifting focus.

[Sin]

My vote is still for zambi. Even though he's new, he's playing aggressive in the way that he's posting a whole lot, but not putting in much important info.
Then again, neither am I. But like other games, I don't have nearly enough experience as you guys do, nor can I read people well.

My gut just tells me he's mafia, for now, until we got more useful info.

As of right now though, my suspicions are on *BLANK* cause I have no fucking idea yet, BUT I do think most of everyone is town, for now.
Regardless as of this moment, I'm going with Zambi.
If everyone thinks a no lynch is better than POSSIBLY lynching a power role, I'm up for it. But waiting on everyone's response in trying to figure out who's who would be better.
Taking time and narrowing it down is better than hurrying with the lynch.

Zambi's activity within the thread is refreshing. Since he's getting FOS'd, his defending himself is rational. It's not like he's just posting random answers to his behavior. He's playing the game pretty well so far, aside from some of his filler.

I think I'll have a read through of the entire thread myself since we're getting up there in pages.

[SCRIBBLE]

We should all expect this game to drag on and not try to rush anything. The more or less people contribute the more information we can extract from those behaviors.

If you are town sided and are "ok" being lynched as tribute then you are not helping town, even if you are VT. Voting for someone with the consideration they may be town can seem scummy but you have to weigh the costs against the benefits.

- - - Updated - - -

I recommend everyone do a read through, it is enlightening to see the thread as a whole.

[I'm a zambi]

Zambi's activity within the thread is refreshing.

Why thank you!

Since he's getting FOS'd, his defending himself is rational. It's not like he's just posting random answers to his behavior.

Yup.

He's playing the game pretty well so far, aside from some of his filler.

[SCRIBBLE]

K.I.S.S.: http://www.ibisgaming.com/forums/pri...?t=12535&pp=40

[I'm a zambi]

We should all expect this game to drag on and not try to rush anything.

Alright.
Unvote Phil

If you are town sided and are "ok" being lynched as tribute then you are not helping town, even if you are VT.

Well it's not that I'm okay with it, I just see it's headed that direction. And since anything I say is going to be psychoanalyzed to death it's kind of a futile effort to resist, since resisting will be psychoanalyzed as well. I really, honestly, have no clue where Mikey's revelation that I was working with Blade came into play but that would be an interesting twist.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

My vote is still for zambi. Even though he's new, he's playing aggressive in the way that he's posting a whole lot, but not putting in much important info.
Then again, neither am I. But like other games, I don't have nearly enough experience as you guys do, nor can I read people well.

My gut just tells me he's mafia, for now, until we got more useful info.

As of right now though, my suspicions are on *BLANK* cause I have no fucking idea yet, BUT I do think most of everyone is town, for now.
Regardless as of this moment, I'm going with Zambi.
If everyone thinks a no lynch is better than POSSIBLY lynching a power role, I'm up for it. But waiting on everyone's response in trying to figure out who's who would be better.
Taking time and narrowing it down is better than hurrying with the lynch.

Please do everyone here a favor and actually read posts.
As I stated before, no lynch is not bad but we arw not going to no lynch today. Why? Because we have a miss lynch.
We can lynch who ever and as long as it isnt a town pr, we aee just as well off d2 as we are d1.


Why do you think its our goal right now to force claim everyone? Are you mad?

Our goal should not be to out everyones roles, aditionally, dont forget that the mafia can talk during day phase, the longer this day lasts, the more refined there night plan can be.

- - - Updated - - -

@zambi, let me edumacate you.

First, you showed genuine shock and awe towards my vote on blade. Fact
Second, the same way you did on the first vote for you. Fact
Third, you did not show the same response for anyone elses first votes. Fact.
Fourth, you and blade tried to hammer pgil with posts almost aeconds apart.

Lastly, you can instigate and test players with more then votes. Example openly fossing another player into a defensive position.

Nothing I do is random, despite what a few here might think.

- - - Updated - - -

@zambi, let me edumacate you.

First, you showed genuine shock and awe towards my vote on blade. Fact
Second, the same way you did on the first vote for you. Fact
Third, you did not show the same response for anyone elses first votes. Fact.
Fourth, you and blade tried to hammer pgil with posts almost aeconds apart.

Lastly, you can instigate and test players with more then votes. Example openly fossing another player into a defensive position.

Nothing I do is random, despite what a few here might think.

[Sin]

Our goal should not be to out everyones roles, aditionally, dont forget that the mafia can talk during day phase, the longer this day lasts, the more refined there night plan can be.

I wouldn't go so far to say it would become more refined, but it would definitely change. It's still pointless to try and understand what the mafiosos are thinking as it becomes WIFOM pretty quickly. Though we can still discern motive from the events of the night phase, ie: fearkilling, nokilling, etc...