WCS themed Mafia Game

[XX0wnsXY]

edited...still thinking. will update with vote

ok so i know we arent supposdd to edit ..i forgot.
i voted sin then realized he isnt playing
unvote
vote cyber
unvote
vote: wolfen..final answer

[Nemesis]

edited...still thinking. will update with vote

ok so i know we arent supposdd to edit ..i forgot.
i voted sin then realized he isnt playing
unvote
vote cyber
unvote
vote: wolfen..final answer

Don't edit your posts, against the rules. If you want to vote you need to do it in colour.


No lynch is by far the best choice for the first day, anyone who says otherwise is an idiot, doesn't know how to play, or is lying to you. There are 14 people in the game, chances are there are four or five aligned mafia roles, all of which already know who the other members are. First day votes benefits the mafia 100% as, since they know who the others are, they can defend that person if they happen to get randomly chosen. They will go along with any random lynch vote on someone who isn't one of them, since it's doing their job for them. The other people who will vote for any lynch are the neutral players, your serial killers or witches, and I can tell you now 100% there is a serial killer in this game. So if you random lynch you're loosing 1 townie almost guaranteed, another townie murdered by the mafia in the night, and then a 60% chance of a third townie being killed by the serial killer (60% because there are more townies then anything else).

You lost the last game by making stupid moves, don't do it again.
Now let’s see what’s been said and what it means:

No, no lynch is statistically the worst move on day one since the mafia is just gonna kill someone anyway and no new information will be gathered, we will be in a worse spot on day 2, down a man and still with no information. Sure day one is a crap shoot, but we need to try and get a mafia person.

Ok, right off the bat either What is lying, or has withheld that he has downs syndrome. We have more than one investigator, and with 14 people, the mafia has to get lucky to kill the cop. Also, would not having two townies die be drastically worse odds than one? Yes, other Barry, it is.

I didn't expect to be followed into doing a No Lynch vote honestly.
But yes, I do agree that we do need some sort of information to go off of. I'm not interested in just pointing our guns at a random person especially this early.

A proper thought? BURN THE WITCH! But ya, this is common sense.

...
did we NOT fucking learn from the last time we played this game?
No-lynching is the worst thing we can do ...
We'll always have crappy information to start off... and some FAGGOT (*cough* spasm * cough*) might fuck shit up for us...
VOTE: Wolfenstinger.
reason? he's the first to vote no-lynch and then change his vote randomly to "voting" as soon as someone pointed out that no-lynching is bad...
besides: fuck yo vagalion bitch!
cant edit: locust immediately agreed with wolf...
What pulled that same shit last time when he was a mafia.
I'm watching you -_-...
I might change my vote depending on what info i get, but my gut tells me smthn is off between the two

Another suspicious or Mexican individual. First states that since we have no information to go off of we shouldn’t make a move, then votes for someone. He also gives a very confusing and poorly worded response. After that begins to throw random people under the bus (heh.) just trying to raise suspicion where there is none.
Multiple times Cyber tries to hint that he’s a good guy, then clearly makes a choice harming the town side.
Now, what I can’t tell you is if this is mafia misdirection (or in Cyber’s case, cartel misdirection) or just more bad play from people who don’t know what they’re doing, but the best bet with games this big is to have half the mafia loud and interactive and throw in disruption whenever they can, and the other guy or two be totally quiet… the more you know.

Also, I dare you to come after me Cyber, is goin be good. Mexican.

---------- Post added at 05:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:04 AM ----------

carm, you just wanna vote me cuz you wanna last longer than me.

Wouldn't be the first time...

[Wolfenstinger]

Do I know what I'm doing? Maybe I'm the killer. Maybe I'm a savior. Who knows? I might be the most stupidest amongst all of us. Or maybe I am playing everyone with a slight of hand. Am I trustworthy or am I deceiving everyone so I may get the last knife in?

Unvote

Our votes may jump as this day goes on. In the mean time, I will be doing a little dance in my corner.
Expect me to come back later to recast my ballot.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

judging by the weak evidence and quick finger pointing, id bet on most of the current mafia, not having replied yet or made any cases as of yet. If you really think about it, this is a WCS version, which would mean, each player was assigned a role based off a race in WCS, i would start thinking about what each race is, its abilities, and where it might fit into a mafia game. Dont focus on the players but more the races origin and role in wcs. I.E. Jack, id bet money on jack and its abilities being a mafia assigned role, with that said we can come to a slight conclusion on what to expect if we vote no lynch the first day. Best thing to do for all of us is work together, share relevant intelligence. Eventually, the bad guys will reveal themselves with information that just does not add up with what everyone else is understanding. I would love to see this turn out a win.

I will reserve my vote tell a few more plead there thoughts.

[Locust]

Am i dumb? yea, I'm dumb. Am I dumb enough to get baited like that if I were mafia?

Unvote

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

this game might actually be successful if it were not so much bickering and rationalizing and more role playing, playing your role. this would provide more clues as towho each player is. then again this is my first time playing o.o

Iustitia omnibus

[Wolfenstinger]

Personally, we're doing fine (somewhat). As long as Day 1 isn't rushed, everyone is still in. It gives everyone time to figure out where everyone stands with one another as well as who is quick to jump the gun etc. Rather than pointing my gun at somebody, I pointed down. And then I pointed it at somebody I knew amongst the crowd (sorry Masskid... )

As it stands of right now, I might get killed off pretty early. And I refuse to see this happen. But, I can't do anything to change the people's opinion of me. I might make the best friends Day 1. Or I have people just wanting to kill me off so I do not become a hassle later. Also, as No Lynch may benefit Mafia, letting this day go on for as long as we can, a No Lynch can be a good thing for Town as well. Depending on who gets killed off at Night means Mafia either picked the people talking the most, the non-talkers (more than likely Town / AFK), or the ones who just don't know what they are doing.

The Mafia will still stand after the first night (even if we got lucky and crippled them). Day 1 is just a Russian Roulette we can all back out of if we choose to.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Personally, we're doing fine (somewhat). As long as Day 1 isn't rushed, everyone is still in. It gives everyone time to figure out where everyone stands with one another as well as who is quick to jump the gun etc. Rather than pointing my gun at somebody, I pointed down. And then I pointed it at somebody I knew amongst the crowd (sorry Masskid... )

As it stands of right now, I might get killed off pretty early. And I refuse to see this happen. But, I can't do anything to change the people's opinion of me. I might make the best friends Day 1. Or I have people just wanting to kill me off so I do not become a hassle later. Also, as No Lynch may benefit Mafia, letting this day go on for as long as we can, a No Lynch can be a good thing for Town as well. Depending on who gets killed off at Night means Mafia either picked the people talking the most, the non-talkers (more than likely Town / AFK), or the ones who just don't know what they are doing.

The Mafia will still stand after the first night (even if we got lucky and crippled them). Day 1 is just a Russian Roulette we can all back out of if we choose to.

Rather than pointing my gun at somebody, I pointed down. And then I pointed it at somebody I knew amongst the crowd. As it stands of right now, I might get killed And I refuse to see this happen. I can't do anything to change the people's opinion of just wanting to kill me off so I do not become a hassle later. No Lynch may benefit Mafia, a No Lynch can be a good thing.

This is your post, broken down in order with all the relevant mafia game data.

[CYBER]

Don't edit your posts, against the rules. If you want to vote you need to do it in colour.


No lynch is by far the best choice for the first day, anyone who says otherwise is an idiot, doesn't know how to play, or is lying to you.

Another suspicious or Mexican individual. First states that since we have no information to go off of we shouldn’t make a move, then votes for someone. He also gives a very confusing and poorly worded response. After that begins to throw random people under the bus (heh.) just trying to raise suspicion where there is none.
Multiple times Cyber tries to hint that he’s a good guy, then clearly makes a choice harming the town side.
Now, what I can’t tell you is if this is mafia misdirection (or in Cyber’s case, cartel misdirection) or just more bad play from people who don’t know what they’re doing, but the best bet with games this big is to have half the mafia loud and interactive and throw in disruption whenever they can, and the other guy or two be totally quiet… the more you know.

Also, I dare you to come after me Cyber, is goin be good. Mexican..

1- ok, here's a few things that are confusing me nemesis.
Now you seem to claim that you're the best player among us (Tom seems to have agreed with this last game, but wtvr).
Last game you said that NO LYNCHING is the worst thing a townie can do because it it loses it's best weapon.
and not there you are telling the exact opposite? Or am i not understanding this correctly?
So yeay or nay on the NO LYNCH votes?

2- When the hell did i say that we shouldn't make a move? I explicitely said that we SHOULD make a move, solely based on the fact that Tom and you (hell even What) told me last time that No lynching is bad. So I'm trying to take a good assumption here. I may not have facts, but I'm trying to get info based on my gut.

3- I'm lost here. How am i hurting townies? again, this is redundant to the "no lynching , yeay or nay" question...

4- There we go again with the mexican shit... Last time i KNEW that you were gonna pull that shit on me... nothing like jumping the "ban the mexican" wagon. Well fuck yo couch nigga!
No but seriously, i dont fucking get it with ur post, it's like begging to say " Hey people! make sure you trust me! im the better player so u have to trust me with your lives even when i'm contradicting myself!"...
That being said, i dont know if i should unvote or keep the vote or vote for locust (based on what brett hinted about falling for wolf's trap... even when i personally believe it was just random...)
I'll have to pm tom about smthn first and update my vote if needed...