Roman Scum: "The Mafia Game." (REGISTERED PLAYERS only here)

[Chikun]

Brett had to have been shielded, everything else is solid and that would mean Mikey is lying and it would also imply that Nemesis is dumb as a sack of shit for trying to convert the son of God to a cult.

I don't buy that. Brett being shielded makes more sense.

Unvote Michelle

Vote Brett

If I'm wrong (I'm not) then lynch me tomorrow

[Blackmage]

Chikun, the way I see it, Brett could only be mafia if he has investigation hindering ability, or Cop wasn't useful. What is your reasoning for him being Mafia? Heck, while I agree Mikey is Nexus, doesn't mean it's Town Nexus. Why is Brett more likely than Mikey? Why would either be more likely than you, who we have no information on?

For what you posted from Blade to prove Brett guilty would require that Locust was a naive cop (only sees Innocent reports), because the same night, he gave us an innocent on Brett.

However, what I really want to know is what Carm has to say.

[Carmichal]

vote blackmage

so hungover dont want to die. tbh my townie power is not op are extremely useful, but if we are going to win we need more town. Blackmage is obv lying. he is either cult or maybe mafia.

[Chikun]

Both of us would be about as equally plausible because there isn't anything implicating you or me. Why I think Brett is mafia? It fits better than Mikey, if he was targeted by cult first night like I proposed the cult would have been killed instead of being redirected. This theory only holds true if you don't honestly believe Nemesis would be that fucking dumb to target the son of God for indoctrination.

Do we agree that the cult is most likely dead?

Do we agree that Michelle is mafia?

[brett friggin favre]

Both of us would be about as equally plausible because there isn't anything implicating you or me. Why I think Brett is mafia? It fits better than Mikey, if he was targeted by cult first night like I proposed the cult would have been killed instead of being redirected. This theory only holds true if you don't honestly believe Nemesis would be that fucking dumb to target the son of God for indoctrination.

Do we agree that the cult is most likely dead?

Do we agree that Michelle is mafia?

i dunno what to make of this. i'm convinced your claim is bs so you're obviously hiding something. what it is, i don't know. carm's play is also proving...worrisome, but you two are going against each other as well, so idk who the last mafia would be. that'd come down to a coin flip.......those don't go well for me.

is there a possibility of having only 1 mafia?

[Chikun]

It really isn't and here's why. Everything in there is entirely plausible and most likely true but here's the thing, your innocence claim, that one thing could throw my whole theory in the shitter of things that are otherwise true. So what it come down to is this, is it more likely that you were shielded from investigation that night or is my entire theory garbage?

[brett friggin favre]

It really isn't and here's why. Everything in there is entirely plausible and most likely true but here's the thing, your innocence claim, that one thing could throw my whole theory in the shitter of things that are otherwise true. So what it come down to is this, is it more likely that you were shielded from investigation that night or is my entire theory garbage?

you're ignoring a simple possibility. i'm giving you the chance now to figure out an alternative role for me, or i'll assume you're intentionally ignoring it, and therefore grasping at straws, which in my mind, with my experience last game in the mafia, puts you in the mafia.

[Chikun]

you're ignoring a simple possibility. i'm giving you the chance now to figure out an alternative role for me, or i'll assume you're intentionally ignoring it, and therefore grasping at straws, which in my mind, with my experience last game in the mafia, puts you in the mafia.

We both know that we aren't going to convince each other of anything so stop the neutrality act. You're mafia and I'm trying to convince Blackmage, Aco, and Mikey of that by providing theories with plausibility rather than your technique of creating distrust and dissension because that's all mafia can do.

---------- Post added at 03:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:48 PM ----------

I'm waiting for Blackmage and Mikey to voice their opinions again.

[brett friggin favre]

blade didn't target me last night. if he did, he wouldn't be dead.

note blackmage's post right after blade's death:
Given Blade was protected by "fate or something more" we might also have had a doctor protect him.

sounds unsure. later, he says that he targeted mikey, confirming him as nexus. but that move doesn't make much sense...KNOWING that there was a cult that he could be protecting (and he did protect), and figuring by namesake there had to be a mafia, he could protect a mafioso...why would he do that? he didn't.

his other claim is that he protected aco. aco is FUCKING JESUS. wasting your protection on JESUS FUCKING CHRIST makes no sense, but it is a great alibi.

locust confirmed me as town, BLADE confirmed blackmage as town. blade was gaining blackmage's favor becuase i was against blade and also suspicious of blackmage. blade knew he had to join forces with blackmage to get rid of me, as confirmed town, and against both of them.

so what happens last night? having aligned with blackmage, blade went to recruit blackmage. blackmage, having known that there was a cult and that blade was the only one mentioning cult on the day before, sent someone, chikun if i'm right, to kill blade. either that, or chikun sent himself to kill blade, and blackmage is the lesser mafia member. something did protect blade, in a way...chikun was roleblocked. by me, Marcus Antonius, Town Roleblocker. blade, in recruiting his new ally, was killed because blackmage was mafia, and as previously stated, usually when cult tries to recruit scum, they're forced to suicide.

let's recap: blackmage and chikun have exchanged their suspicions, but haven't moved hard on each other. i roleblocked chikun last night, suspecting him of being mafia based off blade's info, and we KNOW he was sending pm's to mods...despite his easy to explain VT claim, and despite the fact that EVERYONE ELSE seems to have powers. blackmage, claiming to have saved JESUS, the one person we'd guess doesn't need saving, and conveniently and claiming to have used his protection on mikey, despite problems that could cause, then "suspects" a doctor might have protected blade. nobody comes forward to claim the doctor role, he steps up and does so. blade cleared blackmage, befriending him, who better to recruit? too bad he turned out to be mafia.

not to mention that blackmage was questioning the presence of mafia in the game. with cult as prevalent as it was, that's reasonable...but the game's called "MAFIA". who benefits most from questioning the existence of mafia? mafia.

blackmage and chikun are mafia, unless i'm missing something. this is coming from me re-reading everything just now.

chikun's excuse is lame, blackmage's is better but still heavily flawed. still, blackmage could in theory also be PGO...though i highly doubt it. one thing is true: there has been only 1 killer each night. i roleblock chikun, and there's no kill essentially...except for blade's mistake. in my eyes chikun is surely mafia

for who i blocked nights 1 & 2, i blocked mikey night 1, blackmage night 2.

---------- Post added at 03:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:45 PM ----------

of course i'd forget to add the most important part of my post.

vote: chikun

[Chikun]

I see you read my accusation report and cherry picked who you "roleblocked" to discredit it. Not even counting that your evidence is based entirely on your word where mine is based on direct quotes from Blade's helpfulness from before he was indoctrinated and details from night scenes.

If you idiots vote to lynch me I hope to Aco that Blackmage has a way to protect himself during the night so mafia can't kill him and end the game with a stalemate. Assuming Aco believes Mikey is town and isn't convinced by the Legion of Doom to lynch him.