Roman Scum: "The Mafia Game." (REGISTERED PLAYERS only here)

[Blackmage]

You know, if Carm is mafia, then maybe Brett is mafia, and that's why she didn't kill him!

Wasn't it suggested that Carm would be more active if she was Mafia, prior to that night? Perhaps Blade agreed, and tried it anyway. However, I still think he targeted Mikey.

[Chikun]

You know, if Carm is mafia, then maybe Brett is mafia

I think someone suggested that.

[brett friggin favre]

You know, if Carm is mafia, then maybe Brett is mafia, and that's why she didn't kill him!

Wasn't it suggested that Carm would be more active if she was Mafia, prior to that night? Perhaps Blade agreed, and tried it anyway. However, I still think he targeted Mikey.

could be. i do believe that carm's a prime suspect here but here's the thing: our only evidence on carm is lack of evidence, lack of activity, that sort of stuff. whereas we pretty much know chikun's hiding something. between the two it's a bit of a coin flip but chikun's given us more, so i'm much more willing to vote chikun than carm. carm has no story, chikun's story is swiss cheese.

[Blackmage]

Chikun: That was a joke, just metagaming. While it's possible, if she's not Godfather, it's mostly moot anyway.

Brett, I agree, Carm's only problem is that she is silent. She also got really unlucky with the timing of this day. However, with three players MIA and time running out, 20 minutes if we go by night report, 5ish hours if we go by Cyber's vote count, we need to decide something. Not knowing the exact time hurts too. However, there's a reason I haven't voted for Carm yet.

Could the Gods of Olympus give us an exact deadline?

[brett friggin favre]

Could the Gods of Olympus give us an exact deadline?

^^^^^

also with chikun pushing so hard for carm, it's clear the mafia isn't comprised of the 2 of them...unless she just really pissed him off and he wants to throw her under the bus...which is seeming a bit more likely now that i've said it...

still, for my money, chikun's mafia. that's the closest i got to a sure vote, as for tomorrow, we'll be in much better shape if we get that one nailed down: most likely 1 mafia vs 4 town.

[Chikun]

... Are we getting an extension then since we need 4 to lynch?

Going to need everyone to pass a lynch at this point and leaving it in the hands of the Gods is going to be more detrimental to town than mafia, statistically speaking.

[What]

Statistically speaking, you have a deadline, no one has come to us saying that they are too busy to continue and need to be replaced. Do not expect an extension.

[brett friggin favre]

Statistically speaking, you have a deadline, no one has come to us saying that they are too busy to continue and need to be replaced. Do not expect an extension.

some of them may be too busy to come to you and ask for an extension, i've been posting more about carm's schedule than she's been posting.

also, we ask again, when is this deadline of which you speak, o chosen one?

[What]

Before the Morrow

---------- Post added at 07:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:46 PM ----------

Though Mikey has been afk, so I'll try and find out whats up with that.

[brett friggin favre]

i'll take that to mean midnight ET. meaning carm certainly will not be back in time.

that leaves 5 of us total, and there have really been only 3 of us doing most of the posting. 4 need to agree on a vote.

i appeal now to blackmage, mikey, and aco: not voting for chikun at this point is essentially trusting that he won't be misleading you. i feel like he's barely slipped by in previous days, and i feel like his excuses are more hole-y than aco's birth. he's the last guy i trust right now, and with the little info we have, our best bet is to go for the least trustworthy among us. all the rest is speculation, even that based off evidence, and can be explained away.