Prison Break Wars (Mafia)

[Locust]

I personally don't like sharing my food. But that's just me.

The question for those of you looking to NOT go for the no lynch day 1 is who would you be killing? How are you going to decide that?

[Nemesis]

suppose we voted for lunch, what would everyone want? I mean do we each get our own thing or are we going to get a couple dishes and all share?

Can't go wrong with pizza. Or maybe some Nip food.

- - - Updated - - -

The question for those of you looking to NOT go for the no lynch day 1 is who would you be killing? How are you going to decide that?

what do you mean?

[Locust]

I'm asking if you don't want to vote for a no lynch on day one how do you want to plan on deciding who you're going to want to lynch.

[Blackmage]

Okay, for the people suggesting a info gathering day, how are we planning on getting information? Do we think we have more than one cop/investigator? If it's more than one, how reliable do we think it is? While I hope it wouldn't be sanity cops, a number (such as watchers/trackers/voyeurs) don't tell alignment, some (sensor, forensic) require lynches, bodies or something strange. Also, to get the information, we require an investigator outing himself, and possibly an ally.

For example, with a working cop, I see the following possible results of his night. 1. He finds the guy that was killed, we learn nothing. 2. He's killed, we learn nothing. 3. He finds an innocent. 4. He finds a scum. 5. He gets false information, due to Godfather or Roleblocker or Bus, ect. The first two mean he can't give any information. The 3rd means we out our cop, but have 2 clears, or else end up getting no information. The fourth means we have a free kill and an outed cop, or we have a gambling cop and no new info. The fifth case means we either have no new info, or we get in trouble.

If instead people are thinking we should do follow the cop, I'd vote against. If they have a strongman, Cop's dead right away. If they have a roleblocker, we never get info.

Locust: We pick someone by consensus, in this case, I'd probably aim for a newbie to get them in on the action, force them to role claim or die, and continue this process till we've either screwed ourselves, or found someone expendable/unbelievable. When I say expendable, I don't necessarily mean the first VT claim because we probably would hit one of those early on, but we wouldn't want to get more than 2 or 3 VT before we nuked one to protect the heart of the swarm.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Okay, for the people suggesting a info gathering day, how are we planning on getting information? Do we think we have more than one cop/investigator? If it's more than one, how reliable do we think it is? While I hope it wouldn't be sanity cops, a number (such as watchers/trackers/voyeurs) don't tell alignment, some (sensor, forensic) require lynches, bodies or something strange. Also, to get the information, we require an investigator outing himself, and possibly an ally.

For example, with a working cop, I see the following possible results of his night. 1. He finds the guy that was killed, we learn nothing. 2. He's killed, we learn nothing. 3. He finds an innocent. 4. He finds a scum. 5. He gets false information, due to Godfather or Roleblocker or Bus, ect. The first two mean he can't give any information. The 3rd means we out our cop, but have 2 clears, or else end up getting no information. The fourth means we have a free kill and an outed cop, or we have a gambling cop and no new info. The fifth case means we either have no new info, or we get in trouble.

If instead people are thinking we should do follow the cop, I'd vote against. If they have a strongman, Cop's dead right away. If they have a roleblocker, we never get info.

Locust: We pick someone by consensus, in this case, I'd probably aim for a newbie to get them in on the action, force them to role claim or die, and continue this process till we've either screwed ourselves, or found someone expendable/unbelievable. When I say expendable, I don't necessarily mean the first VT claim because we probably would hit one of those early on, but we wouldn't want to get more than 2 or 3 VT before we nuked one to protect the heart of the swarm.

I dont understand why you are pushing your conversation right now. Speculation with no facts to speculate on, is futile.
Im in favor or no lynch, however, if memory serves me right.... Brett is forever the God Father xD

@locust, it generally boiled down to who was the least active or who caused the most drama and uproar on day 1.

- - - Updated - - -

I dont understand why you are pushing your conversation right now. Speculation with no facts to speculate on, is futile.
Im in favor or no lynch, however, if memory serves me right.... Brett is forever the God Father xD

@locust, it generally boiled down to who was the least active or who caused the most drama and uproar on day 1.

Scratch that blackmage, just re-read your post and understand now that you are suggesting we somehow plan out an info gathering day.

[Nemesis]

Don't need to plan shit. Just need people to talk. People who don't cast themselves as hiding something.

[brett friggin favre]

As I asserted, info can only be gained today in retrospect, in light of the night's events. There's no telling precisely how we can gain info from posts until we have a context to place them in, and info-gatherers with info gathered.

[Old Bastard]

Vote: No Lynch In my opinion this is one of the most interesting parts of the show and what it boils down too, is Betrayal. There will be some of that I guess regardless in this kind of game from what I have gathered, but in the show there is plenty. That's about all I know on the show as it has been quite a long time since I have watched it. Not inactive, just looking for the opportune moment to provide input.

- - - Updated - - -

And with that I will be signing off for the night.

[Blackmage]

Brett: Can you tell me, under what circumstances, the investigator(s) should come out day 2? Also, if there is a situation where you'd have no investigator come out, what would you have us do day 2?

One problem with expecting information is, we know what we get is going to be limited. This is not role madness. Supposing we lose our cop or doc N1, we would be mostly SOL in the night investigation front. Cop either gives us the N1 info, or keeps risking death every night thereafter. If we lose one D1, at least we have words and actions to go by.

I do agree we should try to get information day one, and given we're playing an even numbered game, D1 no lynch is more feasible than an odd number, but I want to be convinced we will be guaranteed information via no lynch like we are with a lynch.

As a side note: No lynch or not, try not to let voting get too high until after the last few stragglers get around. Even if the votes don't matter, what they have to say may.

Second side note: If anyone ever fake votes/unvotes by not colouring it, I probably won't know for a while, because I usually have no coloured text visible. I'll be trying to remember to check them all, but be warned if I start complaining about votes that didn't happen, it's my own fault.

[brett friggin favre]

There will be info tomorrow, unless nobody does anything tonight. Claims will be made tomorrow, and there could be info which counters those claims. There is NOTHING today beyond speculation, and the prospect of having even some info tomorrow is much better than the crapshoot it'd be today.