Supernatural Mafia

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

ok im posting it again for reference.

----------------------------

If we lynch Scribble this is how it will go:

- Scribble is dead and confirmed as Bodyguard Townie
- Proving Nem was lying and mafia aligned
- Kionay will die Night 3

If we lynch Phil:

- Phil is dead and confirmed VT
- Kionay will die Night 3

If we lynch Sin:

- Sin is dead and confirmed VT
- Proving Nem is the Godfather as he came up innocent
- Scribs (if Townie Bodyguard) could protect Kionay
- Kionay investigates Blackmage/Mikey/Aco/Phil

If we lynch Nem:

- Nem is dead and confirmed Townie Roleblocker
- Proving Scribs is bullshitting and couldn't even protect Aco as he stated
- Kionay dies Night 3

All in all, I believe lynching me would yield the best results, IF one of you faggots protects Kionay.

----------------------------------

First off, why would kionay die N3 if phil is lynched? If scribbs is telling the truth.. why cant he protect him N3 if phil is lynched?

What if scribbs gets lynched and ISNT confirmed bodyguard?
Better yet... what if our lynch dosnt confirm what we expect them to be after their claim?

How does you being lynched implicate nem?

thats all

[SCRIBBLE]

If I die and am town then nem is lying, implicating him as mafia. Same thing with sin. If I die an am not town then town still benefits lynching scum.

- - - Updated - - -

Is this shit really that hard to understand? Either you are stupid or playing stupid, aka scum.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

If I die and am town then nem is lying, implicating him as mafia. Same thing with sin. If I die an am not town then town still benefits lynching scum.

- - - Updated - - -

Is this shit really that hard to understand? Either you are stupid or playing stupid, aka scum.

yes actually because it is extremely vague. Im not defending nem by any means but i am having a hard time understanding what the fuck he lied about that would incriminate him if you turn up town after a lynch.

- - - Updated - - -

and for the record, those questions i asked were general, as in i was not personally asking but asking on behalf of everyone who appears to be at odds end with making a god damn decision.

[phil.™]

I'm not all for the pointing finger idea. We could possibly do it, in collaboration with sin's suggestion.
But still, ultimately either lynching sin or scribbs, even nem is top choice. This way, we could get some results.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

I'm not all for the pointing finger idea. We could possibly do it, in collaboration with sin's suggestion.
But still, ultimately either lynching sin or scribbs, even nem is top choice. This way, we could get some results.

and for sake of possible truths, scribbs shoud be the the last option. We need the cops results and if scribbs is in fact telling the truth, we need him at night.

[phil.™]

and for sake of possible truths, scribbs shoud be the the last option. We need the cops results and if scribbs is in fact telling the truth, we need him at night.

Oh of course, if sin or nem is voted, or even me, we need scribbs to protect kion to confirm his role as well.

Anyone else insight who to lynch?

[Nemesis]

The problem with keeping scrubs is he's lying and your cop dies tonight and you get nothing. There's a chance I block the goon tonight and we are safe.

If I block the goon the game is over as long as blade isn't something other than survivor.

[kionay]

The problem with keeping scrubs is he's lying and your cop dies tonight and you get nothing. There's a chance I block the goon tonight and we are safe.

If I block the goon the game is over as long as blade isn't something other than survivor.

only we don't know he's lying, unless you can provide hard proof we have to assume he MIGHT be telling the truth


now, if we all just got back a few pages we'll see Phil acting scummy like a motherfucker

i say we lynch him, if i die during the night then scrib isn't bodyguard (or nem is mafia roleblocking scrib), and if i live then scrib is obviously innocent and we find out about someone else

[phil.™]

The problem with keeping scrubs is he's lying and your cop dies tonight and you get nothing.

How are you so sure about this?

Also I have another idea.

Kion, if you really say you are a cop and I am not lynched, chances are you are going to investigate me, correct? If you plan on investigating me, then we should vote lynch me, as that would be a waste of an investigation for the night.
Scenario: Phil gets lynched, confirmed VT. Scribbs protects kion, if scribbs die, it will confirm his role, and proving nem wrong. Nem is lynched next day. Kion can now investigate someone else who is fishy, that's up to us to decide who is next fishy one.

Scenario: Phil does not get lynched. Scribbs protects kion, kion investigates phil, phil comes up as VT to him. Waste of an investigation.

This plan is so that the cop role is utilized to the max tonight, as it will be much needed. If kion plans to investigate me.. well that's stupid.
Thoughts?

[kionay]

How are you so sure about this?

Also I have another idea.

Kion, if you really say you are a cop and I am not lynched, chances are you are going to investigate me, correct? If you plan on investigating me, then we should vote lynch me, as that would be a waste of an investigation for the night.
Scenario: Phil gets lynched, confirmed VT. Scribbs protects kion, if scribbs die, it will confirm his role, and proving nem wrong. Nem is lynched next day. Kion can now investigate someone else who is fishy, that's up to us to decide who is next fishy one.

Scenario: Phil does not get lynched. Scribbs protects kion, kion investigates phil, phil comes up as VT to him. Waste of an investigation.

This plan is so that the cop role is utilized to the max tonight, as it will be much needed. If kion plans to investigate me.. well that's stupid.
Thoughts?

well since i want to lynch you then of course i don't want to investigate you, that'd just be silly