I still find it strange that scrib can actively lie and doesn't get the votes.

Townies have no reason to lie at all.

Scrib stating he protected Aco is a lie since he was roleblocked and would have been informed of such, save for shitty modding.

Scrib should be lynched for lying. Also, if he was a bodyguard his entire purpose would be to protect important players, letting the doc die is the scummiest thing he could do.