Mafia Game: The Donner Party

[Assassin]

I stand by what I said, if you want to lynch a PR for town then that is your own stupidity.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

I stand by what I said, if you want to lynch a PR for town then that is your own stupidity.

then you are an idiot or are mixing up soft claims by me.

[Assassin]

then you are an idiot or are mixing up soft claims by me.

got it. I retract.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

What is it you think the soft claims were revealing? I mean, i thought i was being obvious d1 and even more obvious d2.
If you are reluctent to retract and your motive was not what i thought it was.. your forcing me to claim.

- - - Updated - - -

this post was started before your above reply.

[Sin]

That little fuck up most likely cost us the win boys.

[hoshiro-]

Im so fucking confused right now, explanations please?

[Sin]

No, anymore explanation will just give scum more ways to stratemegize.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

That little fuck up most likely cost us the win boys.

no, incorrect. In no way shape or form am i to blame. Additionally, i still have a bad taste in my mouth over his posts.

Also, before we proceed any further, i want people to think hard about who they thought was soft claiming roles. Think about it.

We cannot just lynch and go into night. We dont have that luxury atm.
so ill spell out what i think.
If we lynch and we lynch wrong today. It forces vig to no kill.
If we lynch right, it allows the vig to kill.

If we no lynch, it allows the vig to kill.

My speculation that pass was maf, is just that, speculation. So ill break down the numbers, how i do on my note pad during games.

9alive
-1 lynch
-3 all faction kill
Day 3
5 alive
(possible 1 sk 2 maf alive, GG for town...)

9alive
-1 lynch
-2 kills (vig no kills)
day 3
6 alive
(possible 1sk 2 maf)

9alive
nl
-2 kills (vig no kills)
day 3
Best odds given the circumstance

With that said, i think its in towns best interest to pray that the vig hits an anti town role. Doing so would effectively act as a cop, that gets a report several days later on multiple people. However, i fear the vig will die. So, the best option for the vig is to out and claim who they are going to shoot. If the vig dies and can not communicate the following day and the person who the vig claims to shoot, dosnt die. we found the sk.

However, killing off the SK via night kill this late in the game could be bad for town if we go willy nilly and start MLing people. Despite the SK being a anti town role, it also creates balance at this point in the game. If we have 6 players left, 3 town, 1 sk and 2 maf.. and we lynch the SK. Mafia wins after night phase.

This lynch is critical.

[phil.™]

No, anymore explanation will just give scum more ways to stratemegize.

Given that mafia should have a vet (possibility scribs was not the vet mafia) they already caught on.
Or unless, scribbs was the vet mafia and has a newer mafia, then we are in good shape.

Regardless, hosh or ass is a good vote. Ass was not but with his recent post, I'm questioning him.

[Assassin]

Given that mafia should have a vet (possibility scribs was not the vet mafia) they already caught on.
Or unless, scribbs was the vet mafia and has a newer mafia, then we are in good shape.

Regardless, hosh or ass is a good vote. Ass was not but with his recent post, I'm questioning him.

Then you don't actually know what was going on. re read.