Mafia Game: Donner Party 2: Don Harder

[Blackmage]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Donner_Party
http://www.ibisgaming.com/forums/sho...e-Donner-Party

This is the donner party setup.

So, we have a lot of people saying nothing, an open setup with a minor twist (one unconfirmed missing role), a couple people who haven't even voted, the normal Cyber hate. Thanks to Trig, I'm now on the only person with more than one vote. I guess for now I'll leave my vote.

Once we choose someone, we pretty much have to lynch them D1. With no protection, and pretty much every NK being janitored, a good bluff would screw us. However, step one is deciding who to go for. We'll probably hit town day one, but the vote will be at least half town no matter what. The town has a few weapons, we need to use them.

(Parenthesis are who voted for them)

Ass (Pass)
BM
Blade
CYBER (Scrib)
zambi
Pass (BM, Trig)
Rosie
SCRIB (Stars)
Stars
Trig (Rosie)
What (Cyber)

No Votes: Blade, What, Zambi, Ass

[What]

Once we choose someone, we pretty much have to lynch them D1. With no protection, and pretty much every NK being janitored, a good bluff would screw us. However, step one is deciding who to go for. We'll probably hit town day one, but the vote will be at least half town no matter what. The town has a few weapons, we need to use them.

This.

Once we choose someone - Cyber was clearly chosen, as said before, whether by boredom or poor planning.

We pretty much have to lynch them D1 - You did not want to do this. ie not following your own plan.

later in defense of me saying your plan was terrible you said . "Please, tell me what's wrong with stubbornly lynching once we've chosen someone? Which claim should we let live?" post126. Again, further hammering home that you deciding not vote Cyber was you not following your own plan.

Then - "My plan was we DECIDE someone to lynch. I did not say bloody wagon the first person to get some votes" - This is when you start playing with the language pretending you didn't choose to not follow your own plan. I mean you are basically arguing over the difference of Choose and Decide, and the wagon thing is pretty much the same as " stubbornly lynching once we've chosen someone."


Then - "5 people had decided. Which is not even half" post 140 Had we reached half, a lynch would have occurred as that is how these games work. And who could have been that person to put us over the half.........


You "decided" not to follow your own plan. I'm really not seeing how anyone else could not see this as well. The decision had been made, I could easily have said nothing about my suspicions of you and he would be dead, but I did, you went "oh shit!" and knee jerk voted, not realizing at the time it meant not following your own plan. Now you are scrambling and its hilarious. Nice bluff thinking I wouldnt bother getting the quotes.

- - - Updated - - -

I've played with bad mods like you before, so why would I rule out a possibility?

Yep, keep swinging wild, some excuse is bound to convince people soon right?

- - - Updated - - -

You realized you got caught, now you want to play with semantics and pretend it never happened. Cheerio

- - - Updated - - -

Your plan was basically "We can't dick around and vote for a bunch of different people, we need to commit since not doing so would have terrible consequences"
This sounded like bullshit but ok, and then you decide to not follow through which by your own plan would mean you were making a terrible decision, which is why all of this is hilarious.

[Assassin]

actually come to think of it...what is up blade? vote blade

[BladeTwinSwords]

actually come to think of it...what is up blade? vote blade

Not too much. Just catching up on the thread. I don't really have any info at this time because it's Day 1 and we have nothing to go on.

[What]

Blade is almost always online, either steam or here. He is probably one of the least likely people to go AFK for real, though he does like to play around in these games, like his unforced day 1 Jester claim in the last game.

Pass may disappear suddenly due to his job, but, except for the last spyfall game, its never exceeded 24 hours.

Trigger seems to disappear for large swaths of time for various reasons.

But aside from all that, no one is likely to garner the AFK vote, at least as it stands now.

[Assassin]

unvote

[x k i N G x]

uban me -.-

[SCRIBBLE]

uban me -.-

vote king scum

[Passarelli]

I've been checking a few times a day. Nothing interesting has happened other than Assassin calling Scribble "partner". So I haven't felt the need to take time to post when I've been pretty busy.

[Assassin]

Lol I was drawing the correlation between him and what because he came to his defense. Gotta draw some talking out somewhere.