This is bullshit, but sometimes bullshit happens. Napster, in theory, never should have been shut down originally, but it did.

Even if it does go through, the RIAA is retarded. People are just going to find as new way around it. So instead of sharing MP3',s people will start zipping or pgp'ing their files. There's no way to prove that a PGP file is actually the mp3 file unless you have someone's key. All it's going to do is just drive up the cost of internet access because people are going to start suing ISP's.