I'm glad you asked! Well, here's my brief rundown of the maps and how they need improvement for WCS gameplay. These are things that I'm more focused on as a player as well as a mapper, so I realize they're not obvious to everyone, but the less obvious sometimes makes or breaks whether a map is mediocre, awesome, or just plain sucks potatoes.
Dolls:
problems ~
a. violates the 'no free/pickup weapons' on a map rule (tmp in the mousetrap)
b. has graphical errors (minor, but they are present)
c. contains sections that are not quite sized well for smooth playability (like jump heights, doorways, etc)
d. some argue that it should be recolored
solutions ~ removing the TMP, moving the mousetrap to a more inopportune position, resizing the (cereal?) box leaning against the bed, fixing the ladder sizes/positions so players don't get thrown so easily and replacing some textures, but that's more of a preference thing
Italy:
problems ~
a. skybox is far too low for flying races
b. there are far too many player clip brushes that prevent access to rooftops, etc
c. doorways, halls and other sections have objects protruding from them, sometimes causing random death when a particularly fast race bounces off one surface and hits another
solutions ~ a higher skybox, access to more rooftops (admittedly, this will open up the map for flying/teleporting races so I would opt to add ladder access to some rooftops as well), adding clip brushes to "smooth out" object/player collisions
Though these seem like small things, the playability can change drastically with a few minor changes. The idea for dolls is to make access for the less OP races to reach the bomb site a bit more easily and quickly, making the playing field a bit more even. The same kind of goes for my ideas with italy, being that the T side can camp the house all day, while shooting out the windows. Access to rooftops, for one, can make it a bit easier to sneak up on them and create a more interesting perspective. I dig some of the other italy remakes, but they are not designed with WCS in mind. One prime example is the ceiling of the map on the far left side (coming from CT) where flying races leap over an invisible wall and get stuck behind the map. I've already fixed most of the issues in italy and it's nearly ready for compiling, I just need to make some adjustments to the lighting concerning the skybox changes.
I hope this makes sense.![]()
======================
It's my stomach.... I'm hungry!
======================
can you PLEASE fix the dolls one in the following spots that cause you to die if you walked or tele'd there?
CT spawn, if u teleport to the corner where the doll is , you die.
ct spawn as well, if u teleport to the corner along the vent line, u die.
Ct spawn as well, if u teleport towards the entrance of the vent, i die.
Drawer below the bookcase facing the spawn, bomb gets stuck between the tiny boxes in that drawer, if u walk in to pick it up, u die.
basically ever triangle shaped corner is a deathtrap...
A: Skybox is fine, one of the things which blows about custom maps is that the skybox is too high. It becomes far too easy for flying races to rush spawns, hide in areas, and run away. As someone who plays vagalion alot on italy, its one of the better maps for the race. And santa gets around just fine, maybe too fine, the way it is. raising the skybox breaks the map, it doesnt fix it,
B:The rooftops are better off without access, as becomes apparent on Italy_tactik, much better balanced map, the roof part is one of the stupidest things in the map, especially since its too easy to disappear into textures. Same as skybox issue, making it bigger breaks the map, doesnt fix it.
C: Never have seen a race die from moving too fast in Italy, or any other map for that case. Only the Vaga's and spider have issue with these things, and that is a result of speed and angle more than objects sticking out, especially on italy where this has never been an issue.
As far as Dolls, meh whatever tmp and mousetraps whatever.
I hit Brett right in the feels.
The reason for raising the skybox is to open up the map. Italy is one of those maps that needs it, because it's too T sided. I've seen you stack T yourself, What. Maybe you don't want that handicap to go away, but the purpose is for an even playing field. The skybox was made for regular, while it causes blockage problems for wcs, as well as people hiding/getting stuck behind buildings. It's fixed in my remade version. If you saw the decompiled map and knew anything about mapping you'd completely agree that it needs a LOT of work to support wcs gameplay properly.
If the rooftops have better access, it allows for more realism and combative evenness throughout the races. The clip brushes have been problematic in many cases, including crackhouse, which badly needed to be remade. Wanting a challenge for the op races is fine, but hitting invisible walls because a map was poorly made or not wcs friendly is actually what is "broken".
I've seen races bounce off edges of things and hit the floor, dying. These are things you have to pay attention to, and there's no reason to just make a post to try and discredit my ideas. Your opinion is not a fact, so remember that.
It's a rule: no free/pickup guns on maps. Ask any admin.
CYBER: thanks for pointing those parts out... I will decompile and figure out how to improve those things. I have an idea already of what to do.
Lastly, this post is about de_cokehouse to replace crackhouse (both of them), so I'm sorry for getting off subject.
Peace.
---------- Post added at 02:08 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:00 AM ----------
Oh, sorry about forgetting to address this one: "the roof part is one of the stupidest things in the map, especially since its too easy to disappear into textures"
That happens because of illusionary brushes (in a 3D skybox, for example) and badly placed clip brushes (invisible but impassable). Those are all fixed. I will post the map in another thread and you can see for yourself.![]()
======================
It's my stomach.... I'm hungry!
======================
Still stupid, you havent been on WCS enough to see how terrible open skyboxes are. Try playing on Inferno Fog, or dust_aftergo and you'd see there awful. Open sky boxes are also one of the reasons maps like battelship are complete garbage for wcs. You think you balancing for each side, but all your doing is making it easier to race whore.
And also, OMG!!!! Team stacking, I've never heard of such a thing! That clearly never happens in the server.
Also, Name one race other than spider or vaga's that moves so fast it gets killed on a texture in Italy. Never happens.
really, kids these days...
Last edited by What; 11-18-2012 at 02:46 AM.
I hit Brett right in the feels.
Please feel free to pm me if you have ideas, but shooting down other ideas isn't helpful. This thread is not for arguing your point into the ground in a poor attempt to convince me of your opinion. Put that elsewhere. Thanks.
======================
It's my stomach.... I'm hungry!
======================
LOLZ
You seem to be confusing my critique of the problems with your idea as non-sensical shooting down of your idea. All thoughts about something are not gonna be supportive.
Also, not trying to convince you, since I don't need to, but on a thread where you layout the "problems" with a map, you have to expect a response to those supposed problems especially when they are as ill conceived as the one's you posted.
Last edited by What; 11-18-2012 at 03:11 AM.
I hit Brett right in the feels.
yeahh...sorry. but there was 1 sentence in what you wrote which is valid. the free tmp (while not a very major thing) should go. that's it. don't fuck with those maps otherwise. they're awesome as they currently are.
it seems to me the 'problems' you bring up are the end result of people deciding that they would rather bitch and complain, instead of adapting their strategy slightly or even (now is the time for gasping), LEARNING THE MAPS. other than the tmp on dolls, (and the completely retarded color-based complaints), these issues can be solved by players not being lazy fucks and actually putting some effort into learning some shit. it's pretty obvious after the first one or two times what place(s) kill you on italy or dolls, if you enter them wrong...so you either don't enter them that way, or you keep dying.
To be fair aco, dolls is very restricting for the races. Unless u have a flyer or tele race or unbelieavably low gravity, it's hard to reach the bombsite... If anything there show be a ladder on the wall between ct spawn and the vent bookcase to facilitate non-teleporters... Its fine as is for playability, but not diversity. U're forced to stick to a handful of races here. No one feels like playing a respawner or shadow or any race that makes it hard for them to go plant or defuse the bomb. Currently u literally have to jump hoops around the map through the drawers in order to get there... Just saying , it's not fair. But no other change other that the glithes i mentionned earlier should be fixed. And removig the tmps.