Blade's Mafia Game of Randomness

[Passarelli]

Mikey, are you insane? Still trying to let a rod exist? A redirector I could believe, but a Rod? 3 people have argued against the existence of a rod, based on night stuff. Unless all 3 of us are scum, there is no Rod. I doubt that there is another protective role, but it is possible.

Not only that, why would mafia risk redirecting onto their kill target? If they knew there wasn't a doctor or that he was dead, I could see it, but why increase the chances that the kill target would be protected?


At this point, I think lynching Mikey would be the most useful. Nemesis's answer was pretty scummy, but Mikey still bringing up rod at this point is just as bad.

I somehow knew before this game started I'd be voting for you day 1.

Vote Mikey

[StarsMine]

Unvote sin
Why? because he is the only one who can make a clear argument. Would much rather play with him in the game, mafia or not, he is more useful alive then dead. The opposite of what and cyber.

[What]

Wow, this game is totes hurting my brain now. I saw a glimmer of reason peeking through, and then it just went up in smoke. Nemesis argument for Cyber is terrible. Stars being persuaded by that is worse. Mikey being Mikey is you know, Mikey.

I can lemon lime, can't wait in line. I just dropped 30 grand and froze the hands of time.

[StarsMine]

wait wait wait what?
Nem did something that I was persuided by? I was taking my vote off sin, had nothing to do with mikey or nem.

If your talking about nems comment on cyber, then I still am confused since thats been something I have been saying for multiple games. Cybers meta and unintentional misdirection is a harm to town, always. He fails to understand that.

[What]

Sin and Nem are essentially advocating a policy lynch that would not tell us anything other than that people don't like cyber. And to point this out as I have from the start, Cyber has literally done nothing that Sin claims he does this game that annoys him, or Nemesis. Its like a preemptive strike against something he might do, which is stupid. And no sin, I am not clairvoyant, but you can tell and eliminate things by putting the pieces together. If you're solving a puzzle you want to start with the edges, not a random body piece. You need to the lynch to count for something, it is a strategy I have employed in multiple games and it works since the town has numbers on there side and eventually you get to a point with flavor and peoples comments which makes it impossible for scum to lie about their role or actions. I know you have more ass than brains, but I can not believe you honestly do not understand that. Killing off someone because they might bug you down the road is not only taking a body piece, its doing it blindfolded.


Butterscotch skin while she tells me I'm famous, Would answer your call but I don't owe you no favors

[SCRIBBLE]

People I would think have been acting scummy and should be considered for lynch based off Passerelli's hints to what he is, and what's hard claim:

1. Sin - has been scumtastic, arguing against the idea that we would get little to no more info from lynching the people that have claimed something than we would other people who have not. He has has been using WIFOM out of context, it is not some blanket term you can just use when people are outing suspicions based on behavior. Also claimed what was making appeals to emotion while doing just that himself, speaking for the town as a whole.

2. Brett - you have been less helpful than cyber and have made little input. You seem to be trying the subtle route in convincing people to do things, popping in every so often to show you are not afk but sitting back and watching things unfold.

3. Pass - similar to sin on the failing to see reason in lynching one of the few who claimed something. This is a stretch and only a thought but he could very well be working with sin based on his last vote... Thinking it may go in that direction so wants to avoid suspicion by throwing it in early.

4. What - great claim, seriously. I recommend no one protect this deep throat and we let him live so mafia can kill him or we lynch him and we either get rid of the dude we would have to protect until the end of the game or get rid of a very bold liar. Either way, we do not have any use for a day 1 claimed doctor.

5. Nemesis - not trying and I see no point to keep him around if that is the case.

I am not discounting the rod theory until day 2. Claims are just words until proven. A rod may not be likely but I am not going to be herded into this idea that it is not possible despite how arbitrary it seems. I do not like the timing of sin's fruit, passerelli's softing, and star's adamant surety. This is not by any means my favorite avenue, I much prefer the other options offered but I see no point in ignoring a possibility.

I will sleep on who to vote for of the four I listed, I have been traveling for the past two days to make it back stateside and am exhausted.

[Nemesis]

ok this is gone on too long, it's time to make our final votes and get this day moving, nothing can be learned that we didn't get 10 pages ago. Let's push everyone to vote, those who refuse should be the new targets, this is getting ridiculous.

[Passarelli]

Scribble, did you read why I want to lynch Mikey? I honestly just don't see why mafia wouldn't just keep letting town think there is a rod. If you could explain what they would gain, I'd be willing to see your point of view.

- - - Updated - - -

You have to remember that Rod is overall negative utility and would make all night actions meaningless, so disproving that there is a rod is very important--otherwise, I wouldn't have gone to the lengths that I did.

[brett friggin favre]

@scribble:

ok this is gone on too long, it's time to make our final votes and get this day moving, nothing can be learned that we didn't get 10 pages ago. Let's push everyone to vote, those who refuse should be the new targets, this is getting ridiculous.

This is why I haven't been active. Nothing I can say that hasn't already been said, nothing I can learn that hasn't already been learned. I'm not trying to get anyone to do anything. I did some prodding for info, got what I could, made my vote, left it at that. I have nothing more to add at this point, so I'm trying not to be like CyberWhat just beating dead horses all day.

[Nemesis]

Blade, we need a vote count, and if it's allowed a list of whose vote is on whom.

Then the rest of you fuckmooks will make a decision one way or another.