Since things seem to be getting mixed up, here's the events of both the maps in order with ticks:

Vertigo:

tick = 12.5k
"you could always RTV"-theoneandonly
"And I could always cancel vote"-gator ibis.a (aka resolution)

tick = 55k ish:
Disrespect from BlackEagle > slay + kick

tick 60k
"don't abuse"

Kicked for disrespect. < questionable

Tick = 63k
"you open your mouth again you're getting banned"
... really now

tick = 70k
illegal location by blackeagle. Cannont be in a location where you cannot be shot`

tick = 75k
"don't vote kick him"

tick = 78k
Reso getting the rules wrong. Talking in very disrespectful manner to player questioning him.

<was in game> At the end of vertigo BlackEagle sent a message to admins appologizing for his disrespect earlier in the round. He asked gator if he had read the message and gator responds in hostile manner.

cpl_mill:

tick 3k:
deathwish reads the rule to the server
Gator responds by calling him and pass argumentative claims it to be distracting the game. Again reiterates the argument he made the map before which was wrong. (listen until about 10k for his entire statement)

Listen to tick 11.5k

Gets VERY worked up at 12.5k.

BlackEagle says relax and Gator is very worked up and is saying not to tell him to relax.

Tick 16.5k
BlackEagle types in chat`
*DEAD* BlackEagle : relax take it easyyyyy oouuuuu ouuu ouu relax,, take it easyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

Gator responds by saying "BlackEagle you see this shit that you start. You see this?"
BlackEagle states that it's a song
Just listen to the following conversation
At this point me and HK are in admin chat telling him that telling someone to chill out is not disrespect.

Tick 22.5k
BlackEagle asks gator for his age

I remember he asked again in TO ADMIN chat and gator then muted/gagged him.