That fact that she provides 0 evidence is called a policy-lynch. This basically states "We aren't lynching you because we think you are mafia but because you are either providing no help or negatively impacting the progress of the innocents"
I already specifically mentioned policy-lynching Carm and me if we have nothing to go on and explained what policy lynching is
Albeit he didn't really give any ideas because i said it like 6 times so far, but i'd ask the mod to stop stealing my thunder >_< :P
---------- Post added at 01:12 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:09 PM ----------
ACTUALLY.
I just want to test my theory. Carm has 4 votes on her now?
if yes, then I'm willing to bet you guys that if any of Scriblbe, chikun or wolf vote on carm, it will be a lynch lock because i'm almost positive that rape has a passive and forceful quick-hammering ability without him even posting a vote.
This would prove my point that Rape is actually Townie since this role is usually not given to mafia.
Sounds like a dangerous ability later on in the game though. If it is passive that is.
---------- Post added at 01:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:26 PM ----------
also, if rape has this ability i could only find two things he might be.
A Hammerer is a role that passively hammers players. This effect will occur if a player only needs one more vote to be lynched and the Hammerer's vote is not already on the wagon; the Hammerer's vote will be automatically moved to the wagon to secure the lynch. If the Hammerer's vote is already on the wagon, the passive hammer is not possible.
This role is very rarely Town-aligned.
or
Doublevoter can be used as a role modifier or as a role in its own right. It allows the player to cast the equivalent of two votes.
Also, did i miss somthing? OP says we are on day 3?
Personal reform
lawlllll!
Also, i looked back at day 1 votes. I do not see rape placing a vote, so i dont think he is a doublevoter as he would need to actually cast a vote to doublevote. I may be wrong though, as i am using the mafia wiki.
Personal reform
we can still get info from lynching carm. Let me explain, then offer thoughts.
If all votes remain as they are:
If any one other then rape votes the 5th spot and the day ends, Rape is a hammerer
If rape votes as the 5th vote and the day ends, Rape is a double voter
If neither of these happen and we require the 6th vote. Masskid likely had the "hated" modifier, a modifier that requires one less vote to lynch.
Personal reform
im pretty sure masskid already had the hated modified because it took only 5 votes (including rape's implicit vote) to lynch him. I highly doubt rape would both be a forced hammerer and double voter bcos that would be annoying as fuck. So either 1 of the other 4 is a double voter or masskid HAS To be hated townie or else the day would not have ended. Now, seeing that almost everyone who voted on masskid has a vote on carm, and we are at 4 votes and rape has not hammered this yet, i'd safely say that the odds that 1 of those 3 ppl (the 4 voters except wolf) is a double voter . And wolf was throwing his votes around like a mad man, so i doubt he'd be playing with 2 votes like that with a risk of havin ppl banwagoning it. So again, this brings me back to say that i am almost sure masskid was a hated townie, that rape is a quickhammerer, and that carm will definitely get lynched if ANY of the leftover ppl voted except rape. Since he will hammer it
---------- Post added at 02:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:37 PM ----------
At RAPE: this is important. If u ARE what i suspect of a quickhammerer, then trust me, always make sure u VOTE on someone that is unlikely to be lynched until u decide who u really want lynched. And always make sure u are watching the vote counts so that u keep rotating ur temporary CASTED vote until u decide who to really lynch. Reason?? Because if what i read from mikey's wiki snippet is true, u should NOT leave ur vote empty and hanging in the air like u are right now because mafia can use it to their advantage and time it purposely to force u to lynch someone. They might even force u to lynch urself later on in the game if u have not casted a vote. However, by casting ur vote TEMPORARILY on someone UNLIKELY to be lynched and keep track of anyone choochoo-ing ur vote, then u have control over ur own vote, and u basically neutralize ur own negative skill so that u are no longer liable and forced to quickhammer..