Supernatural Mafia

[phil.™]

Sooo, not much discussion or info was given out during the night.
I will hold my vote till we hear from Stan or Sin.

[kionay]

seems it's universally understood that no lynch day 1 is bad

also it seems that if mafia understand keeping quite means they're lynched then lynching the quiet ones is probably not going to lynch mafia

then it seems we're in a bit of a pickle, damned if we do and damned if we don't until someone up and fucks themselves

[Sin]

I've only seen the first season of the show, years ago, but it was decent. As other people have stated voting NL day1 100% helps mafia. I'd be more interested in a longer day 1 honestly. I'll start the claims if need be, I ain't even scurred!

- - - Updated - - -

Fuck it. Got nothing to loooose!

Rufus Turner – (Vanilla Townie)

[Passarelli]

I was not saying to pick someone right away, only that we should lynch someone during day 1. I said this previously and am not sure where the confusion is coming from.

[Nemesis]

I've only seen the first season of the show, years ago, but it was decent. As other people have stated voting NL day1 100% helps mafia. I'd be more interested in a longer day 1 honestly. I'll start the claims if need be, I ain't even scurred!

- - - Updated - - -

Fuck it. Got nothing to loooose!

Rufus Turner – (Vanilla Townie)

This...wasn't a good idea.

[brett friggin favre]

This...wasn't a good idea.

all i remember about sin in mafia was lynching him day 1 of the first game (i think, too lazy to look back) so i don't wanna do that again but yeah wtf?

[Nemesis]

all i remember about sin in mafia was lynching him day 1 of the first game (i think, too lazy to look back) so i don't wanna do that again but yeah wtf?

Well he's either lying or a VT. and we need someone to lynch why not the guy who is either scum or useless?

[Passarelli]

I'm likely going to vote for who I feel has been the scummiest. Someone can use their abilities to see if Sin is lying--I won't be voting on that wagon.

[Old Bastard]

I believe Sin's claim so far, Rufus wasn't a power role in supernatural and he damn sure wasn't a bad guy, so either fake claim and someone else has him or it's actually him. I'm leaning toward it actually being him so far. Phil drives a point about Stan though, O' where art thou, Stan?

[Sin]

It was definitely a good idea, it stirred the pot a little. It gives us townies a better choice. Sure claiming is a last resort kind of thing, but so is no lynching on day one. I'd rather take one for the team (even though it'd be a waste of a day1 lynch since I'm obviously telling the truth), than have these idiots vote no-lynch on day1 and give you scumbags an easy kill, forcing more "guessing games" on day 2.

That being said, I did get votelynched day1 the first game I played, the second game I played I was the Mafia Cleaner and Blade ruined that shitty game by giving out too much information as a Mod (with Nem).

Here's a proposition though. For the townies that don't want to FULL Claim, how about we just start getting NAMES of characters out there? What's the harm in that? If a Mafia member lies, we'll at least know that much when they get counter-claimed.

Why lean towards a lynch on me anyway, Nemesis? Lynching me will only hurt town.