my plan wasn't silly... it was actually a pretty strong plan.
I'd ask the Sin traitor about it.
The only mistake a did was my usual one, and it was trying to be overzealous in helping town, and bam: i'm outed as the journo because some ppl couldn't take a hemp pill and get the hint... fucking Asshole lol...
But no, the plan was solid nemesis, and you know it was solid. Hell i'd ask the MVP this game if the plan was solid. Sin was the plan solid?
Because had it not been for Sin outplaying us, and mafia killing the journo straight, u guys would have been raped.
I wasn't gonna go ahead and out myself as journo immediately if we get a stupid result, i'd actually wait another night as long as im alive to make that person think they weren't watched bcos i knew that the traitor would bait me to jump in and say "no he's lying" if that was the case.
also my plan did NOT involve me revealing BOTH power roles. ONLY the journo IF need be, and onlyt then would it be a 1 mafia for 1 town role trade late game.
Because my plan didn't involve outing the caroler, it wasn't needed.
But the fact that ur stupid ass got caught by brett visiting u, brett had to out himself as caroler to get the 1v1 bcos he was dead nway by ur dumb luck investigation, thus finding out his role.
so yeah.
also mikey, we already talked, and i told u that this whole spy being able to msg "traitor" instead of "trigger" or "Sin" at ANY TIME of teh day was so fucking op.
You should have used the mafiascum version or at least make it so that the traitor needed to msg a PLAYER not a ROLE.
this way, the mafia couldn't simply go "herpa derp, we all suck and we are looking for our traitor herpa derp. our names are idiot, racist , stupid, and tard. post a comment saying "im sexy and i know it" so that we know who the traitor is"
HERPA DERP that was soooooo hard for mafia... right?
If the fucking spy role was player targetted, they'd have the possibility of talking to a town at the time instead of the actual mafia, baiting them to tell them their names, or at least it wouldn't be this easy for mafia to find the traitor and instantly become +1 sized...
mikey stop telling me this setup is a pro awesome setup. the core of it is, but ur application of it on a forum based game and the fool in it just made it stupidly easy for mafia to simply walk in, find their traitor, which as this point is moot because that traitor is now easily part of the mafia because of how easy it was to find him, tell him who his partners are, and then follow instructions every fucking second of the day...
Sin's right, an agent is usually a town counter for that role, in this setup...
mafia had an edge, a very strong edge, including the night 0 shit.
If i didn't get lucky enough and find brett on the first night, and know he was the caroler and that he visited someone who wasn't home, i don't know how teh fuck town would have trusted in brett being the caroler vs nemesis, unless they knew that the jounralist watched the entire damn thing happen and didn't complain...
so town got lucky at start, and for a second we thought we were in a gd place, but the setup was too strong for mafia... especialyl with the traitor immediately being part of the mafia...when sin could have easily gotten one of them lynched by accident, or by swapping role names in the report... etc.
anywho... gg SIN, and only sin. the rest of the mafia were dumb as fuck, especialyl that first guy who got caught instantly, what was his name again? cunt nugget? yeah that's the one.
As for me: "MY PLAN WAS GREAT" (22:20 to 23:06)