I can't really come up with clever shit like you guys and I can't lie for shit so I'm just gonna say what I honestly think. A town sided vengeance wouldn't claim so early in the game like that, you should only do that if you are a mafia and want to avoid getting lynched.

- - - Updated - - -

Even on the site it says claiming vengeful townie is not advised (unless your actually role is vengeful and mafia aligned).