Mikey, are you serious? Cat in the Hat was nothing but a huge troublemaker. Not only that but he had an entourage which would make him a godfather. What role would you have made the Cat in the Hat?

As for it being unbalanced, let's see.

Town roles: Cop, Thief (miller), Voyeur, Blacksmith, Bodyguard, Jailkeeper, and Neighborizor.

Third party roles: Unlyncher (with miller as target) with 1x governor.

Mafia roles: Poisoner, Godfather with 1x janitor.

Not only that, I used epicmafia rules on vests so that it would increase how long poison takes to kill people.

In my opinion, this game was balanced more in town's favor then mafia's.

- - - Updated - - -

Seriously, cry more Mikey. I feed off your tears.