McSugar Daddy 02/10/2015 15:33

[StarsMine]

Lol

http://www.ibisgaming.com/forums/sho...ine-12-31-5-30

Not many who didnt get banned on this forum.
Though mine wasnt for hacking, just by hacking.

[brett friggin favre]

funny how as soon as the ULA get into clan, they're too busy to take a few minutes to watch these demos. guess i'll do it anyway.

~PREVIOUSLY ON BRETT'S REVIEW~

We saw how the demo from blue arena had no evidence whatsoever. Any pre-aiming was the result of coincidence, anticipation, sound, or radar, and no external assistance was required for anything we saw. The lack of prefiring and wide peeks supported this conclusion, but damn near everyone seemed unconvinced. Now, we're back to look at the deagle demo...will it be the same story? Or is this curtains for McSugar Daddy? Find out now, on BRETT'S REVIEW!

-Episode 2-

I'll review EVERY FUCKING KILL. Just because.

1). No pre-aim, wide peek, normal reactions.
2). No pre-aim, open shot, normal reactions.
3). Reacts to gunfire, radar, and teammate death.
4). Continuous
TICK 3000 - if he was walling, he'd see the two enemies there. You might say "he saw them there, and he ran away so he didn't die!" I say, bullshit, he knows he's better than those camping noobs, he has an auto, he knows he can get at least 1 kill there and since GG is about getting kills and not having a high KDR, he'd go for that 10 times out of 10.
5). Follows enemy from where he first saw him, after looking the only place he could be based on teammate movement.
6). Improper crosshair placement, has to adjust to enemy, does so with normal reactions.
7). Again, normal reactions. Sees enemy, aims, scopes, fires.
8). AFK kill
TICK 6000 - Running completely away from the enemy. If walling, he'd know where the dude is. No reason to run to the other side of the map.
9). Snappy, but normal reaction after hearing gunfire.
10). Common spot, normal reactions.
11). Same spot as last time, baits teammate, normal reactions.
12). Again, normal reactions, easy kill on jumping enemy.
TICK 19700 - misses what would've been an easy kill close on his left. Dude ends up killing him. Next round, his delayed peek results in another missed kill.
13). Reacting to sound.
14). Normal reaction to enemy standing in an open corner.
TICK 24200 - again misses an easy kill to his right.
15). Easy kill on enemy with knife.
16). Continuous.
17). Turns AWAY from enemy before turning back to get the kill. This is because he only barely saw the enemy and had already decided to check a corner, before realizing "oh shit, i saw a dude".
18). Camps, easy kill with auto shotty.
TICK 35600 - standard corner to check. Nothing to see here. Doesn't get the kill anyway.
19). He's reacting to the flashlight, knows where to look, gets a kill on someone else first.
20). Runs away from prefiring p90, then goes back for the kill.
21). Now he kills the dude with the flashlight.
22). Easy kill into a pack of 3 enemies. Normal reaction upon seeing them.
23). Skips easier kill on his right to go for an enemy further away. Pays the price. If walling, he'd have taken the fight on his right. Lucky to get the kill he did.
TICK 52500 - same delayed peek we see every time he goes to this spot. Just a note.
24). Easy kill on stationary enemy
25). Delayed peek again, this time it pays off.
26). Easy kill onto scout enemy.

That puts him onto knife, and that's where we stop. One remotely fishy tick, so many others that show he's not walling. There is absolutely nothing here.

For the record, it took about 25 minutes to watch the demo and type up this whole post. Wasn't even close to necessary in order to see this guy isn't walling.

[SCRIBBLE]

Nothing has changed, sometimes we are busy and sometimes we have free time. All three of us work for a living and have done so since we made ULA. Though your review is welcomed, your snark is unnecessary.

I had planned to make this a priority at one point but things came up. Seeing how the player in question has not only been an asshole in most of his comments, he has also made it clear that he does not intend to play in our servers in the future which makes this unban request a low priority on my to-do list.

I skipped over your review of the tics. My respect for your input dwindled after the first sentence of your post. The last two sentences were the last nails in the coffin.

[brett friggin favre]

this thread's been open almost a week, and i've previously pm'd cyber and phil about it. cyber didn't reply, phil said he looked at bluearena and intended to look at deagle with sound, which he will probably be doing tonight based off what he said.

http://www.ibisgaming.com/forums/sho...3027-Unban-GOD - been open nearly a month

http://www.ibisgaming.com/forums/sho...AM_0-1-9243097 - was open nearly 2 weeks

http://www.ibisgaming.com/forums/sho...ritical-Admins - been open nearly 2 weeks

http://www.ibisgaming.com/forums/sho...74-Aero-ibis-a - been open over 2 weeks

i know what it's like when shit gets busy. i worked 14 hours/day while i was ula summer before last, and believe it or not there was indeed still time to take 15-30 minutes to look at demos when i got home.

the problem here isn't that he wants to play here but can't, it's that you have 1 admin, 2 ula, and 1 clan member who voted to ban this dude when there's nothing in the demos to suggest he should be banned. that's a problem. idc whether you respect me or not, idc whether or not you think my snark was necessary, i'm pissed because i thought that in my time here, we'd set higher standards for hacking bans. we worked together to make sure things got handled fairly quickly but also correctly, we picked up the slack when others weren't around and that's just not happening now. it's no pride, all complacency.

[lcoleman]

Thanks brett for taking your time to review

I do have to agree with brett on everything. And it's kind of messed up that admin like ricochet just dismiss what he has to say even tho I'm sure brett did a more thorough analysis of the demos. But apparently if you don't line up with mass opinion here then you're automatically dismissed? Sounds like nazi germany.

This is what I feel happened: I sucked on the sex map at the beginning because well I just joined. Once I warmed up to the server, players, etc. I got a few kills. (admin or people thought I was hacking because of this. Weird because a hacker would destroy as soon as he gets on. Especially one that has played for 6000+ hours. I doubt there would be any need to customize hack settings if you played with hacks on that much).

Next map I've played 1000x on Dogz gungame Death match (which I'm ranked 2nd on and have played every week for the past 7 months) so I know all of the routes and win. (predictable map)

Next map bluearena. The most simple map besides the funtimes maps and get kills because it's honestly one of the most predictable maps in existence. So since I'm not that bad of a shot I get kills and am about to win. Even though I don't do so well when I get to the pistols segment of the gun game.

Do better than the admins on at the time so they look at any tick that may look fishy in the demo without even comparing it to the previous rounds, common sense, radar, nor sound apparently and just say I'm hacking. They say I looked at people through walls? There was probably only one incidence in the blue arena demo where it could have been misconstrued as that but if you look at everything else you would realize it's well in the range of statistical probability. Don't believe me? Then watch minjae during the same demo. Who has more occurrences of looking at someone "through a wall" than in my demo. Look at my previously reply. I list the ticks it looks fishy for both Lily and Minjae.

[phil.™]

Blue arena -- I saw nada.
Few notable ticks I should mention
Where he lines up at beginning, that's normal, strafing back and forth (predicting where headshot level will be) typical.
3600 is the ONLY and i mean ONLY tick i was iffy about cause he whipped around and shot and killed. Play it again, you can hear footsteps. But at normal speed, kinda hard to hear but you can still hear it.
9700 you see a SLIGHT glimpse of pre-fire, i mean SLIGHT glimpse. And that's only because Spray N' Pray was shooting at him prior.
19400 - Same reason as 9700, same person showing the enemy on radar.

Give me a few, let me look deagle.

[phil.™]

Okay for deagle -- ima have to say no walls again.
notable ticks
5000 - one of the fastest reaction times in this demo, or any demos of him. BUT, it's only a 12~14 tick reaction time. Count it, i counted it twice. Thats ~.17-.19 second of a reaction time. Coming from a place where enemies spawn, even my ass would prefire from that spot.
9700 - Scout shot, fast shot right? Wrong, that's a 25 tick shot, that's 1/4 of a second to shoot. I've seen faster at luckier pace. I've done worse. I just shot one time when i meant to reload and i got a headshot 0.0. It happens
23800, seems like prefire, minj was shooting at desert while he was jumping in the air, caught the sound and radar.
35900, seems like prefire behind box, go back to 35400, slow it down, you can see shots fired. YOu can actually see shots fired at fast pace without slowing it down.

My vote is unban. Dude isn't walling.

- - - Updated - - -

Sorry it took so long for me to get to this, busy season for me at work now.

This is now up to zero, do not close.

[lcoleman]

Thank you phil for thoroughly reviewing the demos. I appreciate it

[Steamer]

Some people have 14 hour days, a family, and a multitude of other shit to do you dick. When I get a few minutes of time besides just being able to look I'll come in if zero doesn't handle it. Probably Friday.

Throws feelings and attention at Brett.

I don't recall when I made clan. I do recall not being able to handle an abuse thread until this weekend. So there's that.

[rawrr]

I guess i'll throw in my even though it means nothing

I'm gonna have to agree with Brett and Phil on this one. He's quick and a good shot, hes a smart player and knows what he's doing.
No hacks